The author is Secretary, Jamaat e Islami Hind
Introduction
The importance of masajid in Islam can be understood from the fact that the first thing Prophet Mohammed ﷺ did after migrating to Madina (Hijra) was to construct a masjid. The role of a masjid in those days was not a place for mere rituals. It was the centre of the whole community. Even those who did not believe in Islam used to go to the masjid to fulfil their needs or solve their problems. An important challenge Muslims face today is the need to revitalise this erstwhile status of masajid as a centre of community empowerment and spiritual upliftment.
This can happen only through strategic thinking and planning. In this modern era, where there is an evident decline of moral values, there is an urgent need to revive the role of the masjid to what it was during the golden era of Islamic civilisation between the 7th and 13th centuries. It was the period when Europe was in the Dark Ages. At that juncture in human history, civilisation evolved from masajid in Arabia and spread to other parts of the world. This is because, during the time of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, the masjid was a place where all were welcome, all participated, and all contributed. There is much evidence for this. Masajid were places of worship, education, political discussions, and social interactions. In short, it was the cornerstone of community life.
This brings us to women’s entry and access to the masajid. It is a unique right given to women in Islam. Women have the right to go or not to go to masjid. No one can compel or stop her in this regard. There is flexibility.
At a time when women’s mobility is at an all-time high, keeping them away from masajid can bring more harm and loss to the community than good. However, exemptions are understood as prohibitions; this leads to a host of misunderstandings and tensions. Let us first analyse what Islam says in this regard. For this, we need to check the teachings of the Qur’an first, then the sayings of the Prophet ﷺ and then the practices of the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions. This is the ideal and standard practice for understanding any such question or problem.
What does the Qur’an say?
The Qur’an, at no place, prohibits women from going to masjid for prayers. Wherever the Qur’an talks of establishing prayer, it talks in gender-neutral terms. It applies to both men and women.
Before the five daily prayers, a prayer call or adhaan is pronounced. It is a general invitation to both men and women for prayers, calling the believers to “Come for prayer and come for success”.
According to scholars, anything not explicitly mentioned as haraam (prohibited) is halaal (permissible) in Islam. Moreover, the Qur’an mentions Maryam AS, who has been introduced as the best example for believers. She was dedicated to the care of the masjid.
So, her Lord accepted her with good acceptance and caused her to grow in a good manner and put her in the care of Zachariah. Every time Zachariah entered upon her in the prayer chamber, he found with her provision, He asked, “O Maryam, from where is this coming to you?” She said, “It is from Allah. Indeed, Allah provides for whom He wills without account.” (Qur’an 3:37)
If Maryam (AS)’s act of taking care of the masjid were a negative one, Allah would have mentioned it as such. We can see Allah correcting Prophets like Ibrahim (AS) and Muhammad ﷺ (Refer to the Qur’an 60:4 and 80:1-12).
What we learn from Hadith
The Prophet ﷺ commanded:
“Do not prevent your women from going to the Masajid, and their homes are better for them.” (Narrated by Ahmad and Abu Dawud)
It’s a well-balanced advice by the Prophet Mohammed ﷺ. The problem in the present debate regarding this topic is that people who argue that women should have space in masajid quote only the first part, and those who believe women shouldn’t enter masajid quote the second part. Homes are better for them, but that does not indicate that masajid are bad for them. There are many things regarding which the Prophet said, ‘This is best for you’. But that did not mean that all other acts of worship are bad in comparison. For example, he taught that performing the five times prayer at their earliest time (‘Waqt’) is the best. But that did not mean that performing salah at other times is bad and shouldn’t be performed. Moreover, Allah’s Rasool ﷺ never closed the doors of the masjid on any woman because their houses were better for them.
The following instance illustrates how the first generation used to understand these matters.
“Abdullah Ibn Umar R reported the Prophet (ﷺ) as saying, allow women to visit the masjid at night. A son of his (Bilal) said: I swear by Allah, we shall certainly not allow them because they will defraud. I swear by Allah, we shall not allow them. He (Ibn Umar) abused him and became angry at him and said: I tell you that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: Allow them; yet you say; we shall not allow them.”
Rulings on Swaf (lines or rows of worshippers standing for prayer) and other etiquettes/adaab taught by the Prophet ﷺ indicate that he approved, facilitated, and encouraged women to go to masjid and use the opportunity equally as men. After the compulsory prayers, the Prophet ﷺ would remain seated for a few moments along with the men in the congregation to allow women to exit the masjid first.
Umm Salamah RA reported:
“When the Messenger of Allah ﷺ would pray, the women would stand up when he finished his salutation, and he would stay in his position for a short while before standing up.” (Bukhari)
It was narrated that Aisha RA said,
Here, the Prophet did not say not to come to the masjid but taught the etiquette of doing so. If he wanted, he could have said, “Don’t come to the masjid/don’t send women to the masjid,” but he did not.
Practices of the Prophet ﷺ and the early generation
Allah’s Rasool reducing the tilawat (recitation of the Qur’an), hearing the cry of a child: Out of his compassion for women and children, the Prophet ﷺ would shorten his prayer by reducing the recitation of the Qur’an when he heard a child crying.
Anas ibn Malik reported: The Prophet ﷺ said,
“Verily, I might begin the prayer and I intend to prolong it, but then I hear the crying of an infant. I will shorten the prayer as I know his crying will distress his mother.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 710, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 470
He could have advised the mothers not to come to the masjid with their children so that the others could pray without disturbance. But he didn’t. What does that indicate?
Anas (R) reports:
“The Prophet came once into the mosque and saw a rope tied between two pillars. He asked why was the rope put there. People told him: ‘It is for Zainab. When she felt drowsy, she would hold on to it.’ The Prophet said: ‘Take it away. One should pray only when one is fully alert. If one is tired then one should sit down.’” (Al-Bukhari and Muslim)
Ibn Hajar points out that the hadith indicates that it is permissible for women to offer voluntary prayers in the masjid. Had this not been permissible, the Prophet would have made that clear.
It has also been well recorded that the sahabi women performed funeral prayers inside the masjid. One notable narration states that when Sa’d ibn Abi Waqqas passed away, the wives of the Prophet (ﷺ) requested that his body be brought into the masjid so they could offer the funeral prayer for him. The body was placed in front of their apartments, and they prayed for him (Sahih Muslim 973a and 973b). They also offered special prayers during eclipses:
Narrated Fatima bint Al-Mundhir: Asma’ bint Al Bakr said, “I came to ‘Aisha the wife of the Prophet (ﷺ) during the solar eclipse. The people were standing and offering the prayer, and she was also praying. I asked her, ‘What has happened to the people?’ She pointed out with her hand towards the sky and said, ‘Subhan-Allah’. I said, ‘Is there a sign?’ She pointed out in the affirmative. Asma’ further said, “I too then stood up for the prayer till I fainted and then poured water on my head. When Allah’s Messenger ﷺ had finished his prayer, he thanked and praised Allah and said, ‘I have seen at this place of mine what I have never seen even in Paradise and Hell… Sahih al-Bukhari 1053
A comment by Aisha RA is often cited to deny access to masajid for women, but it cannot be taken as proof not to allow women to enter masjid. It was only a hypothetical statement: “If the Prophet of Allah ﷺ was to know the situation of today’s women, then he would surely stop them from coming to masjids” (Bukhari: 869, Muslim: 445). Her objective was not to stop women from going to masjid, but to remind them on the etiquette taught by Allah’s Messenger ﷺ while going to masjid. She herself would go to masjid and never was reported to have stopped any girl or woman from her family or outside it. Also, we should follow what is established by Allah and not the desires and opinions after his last prophet: “Today I have perfected your faith for you, completed My favour upon you, and chosen Islam as your way.” (Qur’an, 5:3)
The fear of fitna (disorder) has been cited as another reason for preventing women from going to masjid. This fear was more prevalent at the time of the Prophet ﷺ, who allowed women to attend masjid. Ironically, as has been observed in many places, women can go anywhere and everywhere except to masjid. This is particularly evident in marketplaces, where families shop together. When it is time for prayer, men enter the nearby masjid while women are often seen wandering or waiting in the street. This occurs especially during the Maghrib prayer, which is shorter in duration. Furthermore, taking a break to pray amidst shopping might encourage women to reflect on the guidelines of Allah and His Messenger ﷺ regarding spending. While it is positive that some marketplaces offer facilities for women at masajid, such options are not as commonly available as necessary.
Some of the companions of the Prophet ﷺ did not like women going to masjid. Among them was Umar Ibn Khattab RA. But his wife Aatikah Bint Zaid used to go. Someone asked her, “When your husband doesn’t like it, why do you go to the masjid. She responded by asking: ‘Then why he is not stopping me?’ (How diplomatically she responded! Something for us to learn as well.) The questioner said, it is because Allah’s Messenger ﷺ has given permission.” She was present in the Masjid for the Fajr (Morning) prayer even when Umar RA was killed. (Bukhari 900). It means they were going to masjid not only for Jumua and Eid but also for the five daily prayers.
Masjid’s role in spiritual and moral growth
The Qur’an emphasizes that both men and women must cultivate their moral and spiritual development. The masjid is, and has always been, a centre of moral and spiritual learning and growth. Women’s participation in masajid can lead to profound spiritual growth not only of those women who attend but also of the entire family and thereby the entire community.
Education or learning that happens automatically. By engaging in salah, Qur’anic studies, listening to the Jumua Khutba (sermon), listening to the recitation of the Imam (the one who leads the prayer), and other spiritual activities, women can deepen their connection with Allah. Knowledge comes before Iman (Belief). Deeni (Religious) education is not organised properly and regularly in every home; it may be interrupted or disorganised if a certain person is travelling or unavailable, or due to a change in routines. So, if whatever happens in masjid is easily accessible to all, it can lead to relatively uninterrupted learning. The Khutba during Jumua prayer serves as a weekly reminder on Taqwa (God consciousness) which is essential in one’s spiritual growth. The atmosphere at masjid helps in focusing, and there is Barakah (Blessing) in the entire surrounding. For centuries, women went to masjid not just for Ibaadaat but also for attending classes and listening to reminders. In those days, women’s Halqas were active in Masjidul Haram, Masjid al-Nabawi, Masjid al-Aqsa, Masjid al-Umawi, etc.
If performing alone at home, one can get lazy or delay the prayer and related activities. That is why Prophet Mohammed ﷺ said,
Abu Ad-Darda said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘There are no three people in a town or encampment among whom prayer is not established, but the Shaitan takes control of them. Therefore, stick to the congregation, for the wolf eats the sheep that strays off on its own.” (Sunan an-Nasa’i 847)
By seeing the other women who are more pious. The participation of elderly and more pious women in masjid helps other women and young girls become more inspired. Moreover, such women automatically spread the culture and legacy of Islam not just by their presence but even by reminding and correcting each other.
How does it help in community empowerment?
Better understanding of the Deen as well as the socio-political situation: Masjid is a public place for discussing issues of concern to Muslims and responding to challenges faced by the community. If women are empowered, the entire community benefits. It helps in nurturing the future generation and enables them to contribute to society. It also promotes social cohesion and understanding. Allah’s Rasool’s deeni majalis (gatherings for religious learning) in the masjid were attended by women. He encouraged active learning.
Women used to ask questions, and he used to appreciate them.
Safiyyah bint Shaybah reported: Aisha, may Allah be pleased with her, said, “How excellent are the women of the Ansar! They do not allow shyness to prevent them from understanding the religion.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 332)
Sometimes, the Prophet ﷺ used to allocate separate time to address only women to ensure that they received the education and awareness that is essential for empowerment.
“The women came to the Prophet (peace be upon him) and said, ‘The men have taken all your time, so please allocate a day for us.’ He then promised them a day on which he met them, advised them, and instructed them.” (Sahih Al Bukhari, Book of Knowledge 101)
Once the Prophet ﷺ noticed that women could not hear the Eid Khutbah properly, so he went to them and addressed them separately:
“Then he went to the women, preached to them, reminded them (of Allah), and instructed them to give charity.” (Bukhari)
Maximum utility out of minimum resources. As we all know, the community is already backwards in countries like India, with immense regional disparity. Arranging separate facilities for educating women on the Deen and Akhlaq (Manners) is very difficult, and such initiatives are not that common for women in such places. One cannot just blame our lack of resources and poverty and remain idle. The community leaders and scholars need to think of the maximum utilisation of whatever is available to even come out of the economic backwardness of the community.
After investing such huge amounts on constructing a building as a masjid, it’s a blunder if it is used only for the five times prayer for men alone, especially because creating a masjid and protecting and maintaining it is all the more difficult. Political interference, changing laws and social environment are making matters more and more difficult for the community. What is wise in this kind of situation is, to utilise the masajid for the community’s Tarbiyat, Tazkiyat and Deeni education and to remember that women are also part of the community. This is the Madina model. In the beginning, they were economically backward, socially downtrodden and there were internal and external threats. But the masajid were vibrant with enriching activities for men, women and children, which enabled them to be socially cultured, economically empowered and politically strong within less than three decades. From the people who lived like slaves to the Jews by borrowing money from them, they were completely transformed into an economically self-sufficient society where they couldn’t find a deserving person to receive zakat. Not only in Madina, but even in the states where women started going to masjid more commonly than others in India (especially in certain parts of the south), one can see the difference in the confidence level of women, their deeni knowledge and courage which in turn has contributed to the overall development of the community in all fields.
Way forward and suggestions
Provide accessible and comfortable spaces in masajid. A dignified place in masjid can facilitate in nurturing the spirits of women and satisfy their intellect. Those spaces shouldn’t be small, dingy, secluded or airless quarters. Make sure that those spaces are clean, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasing.
- Proper sound system. A study of the masajid in India where women are provided spaces can show that they are mostly (not all) without a proper sound system for women to hear the Imam clearly during Khutba and prayer. This would result in more women opting to pray at home, and consequently, the spaces will get reduced or even removed.
- Safe and proper pathways and entrance: This is very important as women often come with small kids. Also, elderly women find it difficult to easily access the prayer space. A separate, proper entrance will also help avoid too much mingling with men.
- Provide facilities to attend and actively involve and contribute as speakers, volunteers, donors etc. in common awareness programs and other activities in and around the masjid. According to Dr. Hatem Al Haj former Dean of Islamic Studies in English at Mishkah University and a senior member of the Fatwa Committee of AMJA (Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America, “We have this mental image of a masjid as a sterile, extremely quiet place where people pray together and disperse thereafter. This causes some to enforce many restrictions in the masjid that would eventually make it an unwelcoming place for children and families, even to adult men.”
If women are alienated, it can have profound consequences for younger generations of the ummah. When children are taught that Islam treats both men and women as spiritual equals, and that Islam has given women unprecedented rights, and then observe that the practice contradicts the principles, their willingness to adhere to the faith is challenged. Without continued exposure to the masjid in their early and formative years, children, both boys and girls, are less able to integrate into the masjid as they become older. The secondary inclusion of women will surely keep the masjid at the margins of community life development. So, they should also be included in the activities of masjid.
- Home visits by women: In order to ensure proper communication between the individuals of the community and the Imam as well as the administrators of the masjid, home visits should happen. The leaders, while visiting, have to find time to interact with the women and children of the house, so that they feel connected and encouraged. This will also benefit in understanding the religious, social, and financial condition of the family, which would in turn help in the welfare activities of the masjid and reach the right persons and families. All these would be more effective if women were included in the home visit delegation, or women can also have separate visits. The advantage is they would be able to interact with the women and children more empathetically and build rapport.
- Encourage and involve women and children in the upkeep of the area: In many masajid, women’s spaces are often neglected and taken the least care of in maintenance and cleaning. This happens not intentionally but because the masjid authorities never go and check the area, and because it is dirty and dusty, many women stop coming. The easiest solution is to sensitise women and children and encourage and involve them in the area’s upkeep. The positive result has been seen in those masajid where this is being practised.
- Awareness programs tailored to women’s needs. After carefully studying women’s needs, the masjid can initiate programs and facilities, especially for women. Doubts related to daily fiqh about women’s physical conditions can arise. Many women might not be aware of the masjid’s etiquette. Sessions involving women can be conducted on these topics separately.
- Marriage/family counselling and settling disputes. Masjid should provide pre- and post- marital counselling not only to the girls but the groom and the immediate family members. Before solemnising the marriage, the masjid should ensure that both the bride and the groom are properly educated in running an Islamic family as per the teachings of the Qur’an and Sunnah. There should be a balanced approach in inculcating both rights and duties. This can be made possible by involving properly trained and qualified women as counsellors. While settling disputes in marriage, the involvement of women will greatly help in understanding women’s problems and explaining the matters clearly. Women can understand women’s problems better and the lady in dispute will be able to open up and speak freely to a woman. So, women should also be involved and trained to be mediators in disputes. It will lead to more inclusive decisions.
- Literacy programs: As per data, we all know that in India many women in the community are illiterate even in this modern age. This should never happen for a community that follows the Qur’an, the first revealed verse of which begins with the command to read (Qur’an 96:1). So, the administrators of masajid should decide that no woman (as well as men if any) under this mohalla should be illiterate. If such a decision is taken, we can easily achieve 100% literacy.
- Participation in decision-making process: Women should be included in masjid or mohalla committees for a stronger and more inclusive community. This will help to keep away the enemies of Islam who misguide the women, especially young girls, in the name of liberalism. It can help uphold the core values of Islam, which are: justice, equity and compassion. The growth and development of the masjid is stunted when the full human potential of all its members, including women and girls, cannot be harnessed. The danger is when their efforts to contribute their talents to community development through their masjid are circumvented; they work independently, which may reinforce divisions over the long term. It is a proven fact that the participation of women in masjid committees brings many changes in the general mohalla level administration and how they deal with different matters. This helps women acquire leadership skills that can be utilised to empower the community. If they are mothers, they will also nurture the future generations more substantively. The general saying that ‘Involve me and I learn’ is applicable here too. Now that more Muslim women are well qualified and educated, the community leaders should provide enough space for them to contribute and utilise their skills.
- Can appoint a full-time female caretaker or an official: This practice has been seen in some masajid worldwide. Adjacent to the women’s prayer area, one can find a separate office, and a woman sits there to address women’s matters.
- Separate subcommittees can also take care of different activities related to women and children.
- Work from home possibilities like sending messages, preparing posters, collecting data, etc., can be assigned to the women who come to the masjid regularly to harness their talents for the betterment of the community.
- Special provisions for elderly women: Elderly women are the most neglected. Their presence in the masjid is a blessing. The new generation can learn much from them. The legacy and culture of the community can be easily transferred from one generation to another by providing them with comfortable and respectable spaces. For this, there has to be a proper review of making masajid accessible, beyond putting chairs and wheelchair access.
- Suggestion and complaint service: Imam is the leader of all. Since the Islamic role of a masjid is that of care and compassion, the Imam/Khateeb should be able to know the needs of all. He must be mindful to take ideas from all. Some of the sermons (Khutba) by Allah’s Rasool ﷺ were made as per the suggestions or complaints by women. A wealth of ideas, energy, and experience exists among the women and young girls. This needs to be harnessed to reinvigorate masjid life. For this, a minimum of one complaint and suggestion box should be put up in the women’s area.
- Masjid visits, Information stalls/desks, Interfaith dialogues: Masjids should also welcome and encourage non-Muslim women to enter, inquire, and learn from Muslim women. This, in turn, helps empower Muslim women and clear misconceptions in society.
- Other facilities to attract women and empower the community: As per resource and need, the following facilities can also be arranged in the due course of time. Some of them might be already available in the vicinity or campus. But the community leaders should ensure that the following facilities are made available for their women: library and reading rooms for women, library, activity/play areas for children, clinics, free medical check-ups, legal supports, help desks, supplementary education or extra support in school education for children along with Islamic education, weekend Islamic learning programs and so on. In order to empower economically, masjid committees can provide financial literacy, form self-help groups and micro finance systems, facilitate small-scale sales of the products made by women on a weekly or daily basis through exhibitions, etc.
The empowerment and welfare of a community depend upon its members’ physical and mental health, especially women. To this end, physical fitness training, gymnastics and indoor games can be part of the masjid activities. There should be ample opportunities for women and girls within the protected Islamic environment for entertainment. Otherwise, there are chances that they get attracted to those platforms where there are immoral practices and no care for Islamic etiquette. Some masajid, especially in South India, provide such facilities exclusively for women, like ‘Friday, Fun Day’, etc., which can be made more common for arts and cultural activities.
Bear in mind: The above suggestions are not to be started in one go. But the community leadership should have the vision and strategic planning to include women in the most important centre of it. This way, we can make our masajid more vibrant and attractive for all. The role of women is to approach the right persons, suggest what could be done, and offer their services, too. Working for justice and social welfare is not the duty of men alone:
The believers, both men and women, are guardians of one another. They encourage good and forbid evil, establish prayer and pay alms-tax, and obey Allah and His Messenger. It is they who will be shown Allah’s mercy. Surely Allah is Almighty, All-Wise. (Qur’an, 9:71)
In short, much can be achieved by providing spaces for women in masajid and getting involved in their activities. What is required is a positive mindset and strategic approach. If five women in each mohalla are ready to sacrifice their time for this, and if they are involved, empowered and facilitated, a lot can be changed quickly.
Of course, implementing changes will always involve a commitment of willpower, resources, time, money, and various skills. Changes happen incrementally, step by step. The first step is to audit where we are and make strategic plans to improve. If there is a will, there are ways.
Conclusion
At a time when the masajid are under threat and people wait for an opportunity to confiscate or demolish them, it is the duty of everyone, including men, women, the youth and children, to do whatever they can to protect them and utilise them for the overall welfare of the society. There is no need for any outside interference for this. Our ‘umeed’ (trust) is not in those who do not leave any stone unturned to demonise the community, to divide and marginalise, kill the men in the street for no reason and make the women widows, who use dog whistle language and give hate speeches against the community, put the youth in jail and keep them for years as accused without trial and so on. If they come up with UMEED, we can’t accept it. But we have the Qur’an and the Sunnah, which provide all that is required for women and girls to get justice and honourable treatment. So, it is but foolishness to go behind false promises. If sensitised properly, most community leaders willingly listen to bring the needed change.
Women should also be ready to sacrifice and donate their time and resources to the cause. Remember, rights are always accompanied by responsibilities.


0 Comments