The author is a renowned journalist.
The blatantly unconstitutional actions of the Chief Election Commissioner, Gyanesh Kumar, leading to large-scale deletion of the names of lakhs of bona fide voters in Bihar, West Bengal, Maharashtra, Karnataka and even in the National Capital Territory of Delhi, have caused unprecedented chaos and confusion in the minds of people in this country. Even workers of various political parties, including the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) as well as the opposition Congress, are at a loss to understand the constitutional validity of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) being carried out by the Election Commission, spread across 12 states and Union Territories.
The question of the legality of the SIR came before the Supreme Court of India even before the Bihar Assembly elections in 2025. However, unfortunately, a bench of the Supreme Court led by the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, declined to interfere with the SIR, which continues to create more and more chaos and confusion, leading to even two of the three members of the Election Commission questioning the unilateral actions of the Chief Election Commissioner.
Dissent Within the Commission
According to an excellent report by Ritika Chopra in the Indian Express on Wednesday, 23 September, in 10 months two Election Commissioners objected 14 times to steps taken by the Commission for deleting names and adding names without even informing them or taking their consent. “The objections relate to the core of the EC’s mandate: new voter registration, deletion and restoration of voters in the rolls; filing of appeals against orders restoring voters’ names in the SIR process; and the custody and security of the entire electoral roll itself,” the Express report pointed out.
The most contentious issue raised by the dissenting Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, concerned the change in Form 6. In July 2026, the form that every adult citizen has to fill to become a voter started asking a new question which it had never asked before. Linking the application to the SIR, it asked whether the new voters or their parents or grandparents “exist” in the “electoral roll of the last SIR”. Applicants could not proceed without answering the question.
This, despite the fact that in May Election Commissioner Vivek Joshi had warned in writing that Form 6 could not be changed without the government amending the rules, and the other Commissioner, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, had endorsed Joshi’s view and on 13 August put on record that the change was “unauthorised and illegal” and “must be removed immediately”. That question still remains on Form 6, so much for the “unanimous” working of the Election Commission of India.
Centralising the Electoral Roll
The most important and unique feature of the Election Commission of India is its decentralised operation, whether in the matter of preparation of the electoral roll or conduct of the election. Each constituency’s voters’ list is prepared and controlled by the Electoral Registration Officer (ERO), a statutory authority on the ground, usually the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM) of the area. This list (the electoral roll) now sits on a software, ERONet, and its successor, ECINet. Over the past one year, according to the Indian Express exposé, the two Election Commissioners have repeatedly questioned whether the EROs’ access to the list is being restricted now. In this context, in May this year, Joshi, pointing out the gradual centralisation of the electoral roll database, proposed an audit to certify that “no one, except the concerned statutory authorities, has credentials to make any changes in the voter database”.
In August, Sandhu reiterated the demand and recorded that state-level election officials were reporting “they do not have proper and complete access” to the ERONet portal. In other words, the Commission’s IT Division was itself illegally restricting the freedom of operation given by law to the statutory authorities. In other words, ironically, the two Commissioners said the Commission itself was dismantling the work of its statutory authorities by its own IT Division. It was centralising the voters’ database.
From the above, it is very clear that the Election Commission has been highly compromised and has utterly failed in its constitutional duty to safeguard the sanctity and safety of the electoral roll, without which democracy is reduced to a farce.
The Court’s Moment
Under the circumstances, it is important that the Supreme Court of India immediately step in to sort out the mess and restore the Election Commission to its rightful place in India’s true constitutional framework.
True, a two-judge bench of the Supreme Court on Wednesday, following the devastating exposé of the Election Commission of India by the Indian Express, in an order placed the matter before the Chief Justice of India for constitution of a Constitution Bench to consider the constitutional challenge to the 2023 Election Commission Appointment Law that excludes the Chief Justice of India from the process.
In deciding the matter, for Justice Sharma the main question was whether Parliament was justified in replacing the CJI with a Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. “Whether or not Parliament was justified in not including a neutral selector in the selection committee is an important question arising for the first time before this court. Since this question has not been dealt with in any precedent, it cannot be resolved by the present bench,” Justice Sharma said.
While the appointment of the EC will be taken up by the Constitution Bench, one hopes that the immediate issues facing the Election Commission will be taken up by the Supreme Court on an emergency basis and save the people of India from further disaster!


0 Comments