The author is an educationist, translator, writer & social worker.
‘How much space does Islam actually give women outside the home?’ This is a question that is often asked when the subject of Muslim women and public life comes up. The question itself may need to be reconsidered. Instead of beginning with restrictions and asking what women are allowed to do, perhaps we should begin with the life of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and ask a simpler question: How did women actually live and participate in the first Muslim community?
A closer look at the Qur’an and Sunnah presents a picture that is considerably richer than that of women confined entirely to the private sphere. Women were mothers and wives, certainly, but they were also learners, teachers, worshippers, advisers, transmitters of knowledge, caregivers and participants in the wider life of the community.
The Qur’an itself does not describe believing women as passive members of society. It says: “The believing men and believing women are allies of one another. They enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong…” (Qur’an 9:71). The verse places men and women together in the moral responsibility of building a righteous society. It is difficult to reconcile such shared responsibility with the idea that women have no legitimate role in the public life of the community.
Women in the Masjid
The role of a Masjid in the during the time the Prophet was very comprehensive. It was a place of worship, learning, scholarship, communication and community life. It provides an important window into the social life of Muslim women as they were always present in the masjid. They listened to sermons, asked questions and sought knowledge. They approached the Prophet (pbuh) directly when they needed clarification, including on matters concerning women that they were not hesitant to raise. The Prophet (pbuh) explicitly said, “Do not prevent the women servants of Allah from the masajid.” (Sahih al-Bukhari 900).
A narration from Umm Salamah (RA) describes women praying in the masjid and the Prophet (pbuh) remaining briefly after the prayer so that they could leave before the men. (Sahih al-Bukhari 875). The arrangement demonstrates something important:
the solution to interaction between men and women was not necessarily exclusion. It could be thoughtful organisation within the boundaries of modesty.
Women Who Demanded Knowledge
A group of women once came to the Prophet (pbuh) and pointed out that men were receiving more of his time. They requested a day specifically for their instruction, and the Prophet (pbuh) agreed. He designated a day on which he met them, taught them and instructed them in religious matters. (Sahih al-Bukhari 101),
There is something remarkable about this simple incident. The women did not wait silently for whatever knowledge happened to reach them. They identified a need, articulated it and sought a solution. And the Prophet (pbuh) did not regard their demand for learning as an unnecessary intrusion into public religious life.
Their example also tells us something about the Islamic understanding of women’s intellectual agency. Women were not merely expected to receive religious knowledge second-hand through their male relatives. Instead, they had a direct claim to learning. That claim produced women of extraordinary scholarship. Aisha (RA) became one of the most important authorities on the life and teachings of the Prophet (pbuh). Companions of the Prophet and later scholars sought her knowledge. She corrected misunderstandings, explained Prophetic traditions and offered her judgement on matters of religion and law. Her intellectual contribution was not limited to women, men themselves learned from her.
The history of Islam therefore contains a powerful precedent for women which should make us pause before speaking of women’s education merely as a modern concession. Women were not simply educated so that they could become better wives or mothers. They could become teachers, transmitters of knowledge and authorities in their own right.
Women in Versatile Roles
Women’s contribution did not confine to the intellectual sphere either. The community formed under the Prophet’s guidance called upon women in times of need. Women accompanied expeditions, rode horses, provided water, food and medical care to the soldiers and took up arms whenever need arose.
Nusibah bint Kaʿb (RA) took part in battles and events at Uhud, Hudaibya, Khaybar, Hunayn, and the Battle of Yamamah. She actually fought in Uhud. Umar(RA) quotes the Prophet as saying: “Whenever I turned right or left during the Battle of Uhud, I saw her fighting to defend me.”
During that battle, she was with Umm Ayman and Umm Sulaym, the three of them doing their support duty, but when they realized that the unbelievers were winning, they abandoned tending the injured, put down their pails, picked up swords from those who were killed and took part in the actual fighting. During the time of Abu Bakr(RA)’s reign, she joined one of the armies fighting the apostates, and she took part in the actual fighting until Musaylamah, the liar leading the rebellion, was killed.
Following this Prophetic model of women’s participation in public sphere, during the caliphate pf Umar(RA), he appointed al-Shifa bint Abdullah as superintendent of the market. Her post carried judicial and executive responsibilities. It represents a practical authority ordained by the to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong. Umar also appointed Samra bint Nuhayk in the same post in Makkah, and he gave her a whip to punish anyone who cheated or gave short measure. Thus, we can see several examples of women in the early Muslim community taking active part in judicial and executive responsibilities.
Public Participation Does Not Mean Abandoning Family
A woman’s contribution to society can take many forms. Teaching, healthcare, social welfare, counselling, education, charitable work, journalism, scholarship, administration and community service can all become avenues through which she fulfils her responsibility towards society.
The modern discussion sometimes becomes unnecessarily polarised. One side imagines that a woman who enters public life must have abandoned her family and religious identity. The other imagines that liberation requires her to reject every traditional responsibility. Neither picture is adequate. The Prophetic model offers something more balanced. In this model family was important, but family did not erase their identity as members of the wider community. A woman can be a mother and a teacher, she can be a wife and a scholar and she can care for her family and contribute to society. These identities do not compete with each other. The question is not whether a woman belongs either to the home or to society. She belongs to both, although the balance may look different at different stages of her life.
Obviously, Islam places clear ethical boundaries on interaction between men and women. Modesty, dignity, appropriate dress, respectful speech and avoidance of inappropriate relationships remain important. But the existence of boundaries does not automatically imply the elimination of interaction. The women of the first Muslim community lived within those boundaries while still participating in the life of the community.
This distinction is easily lost when cultural practices are treated as though they were divine commandments. Muslim societies, like all societies, have developed customs over centuries. Some of these customs are beautiful and protective and others may reflect particular historical circumstances. The danger arises when every inherited practice concerning women is given the status of an immutable religious rule.
Women as Leaders, Advisers and Decision-makers
The question of leadership requires similar care. Leadership can mean many things. It can mean political authority, but it can also mean intellectual leadership, educational leadership, social leadership, organisational responsibility and moral influence.
The Prophetic period gives us numerous examples of women exercising judgement and influence. Women questioned decisions, offered counsel, narrated religious knowledge and participated in matters affecting the community. Umm Salamah (RA), for instance, is remembered for her wisdom and strategic political counsel. During the treaty of Hudaibya, when the Companions hesitated to respond to the Prophet’s command, Umm Salamah advised him on how to handle the situation. He followed her advice, and the crisis was resolved. This is a particularly powerful example because she wasn’t merely expressing an opinion in a private conversation. Her counsel influenced the Prophet’s handling of a crisis involving the entire community.
As quoted in the beginning, the Qur’an itself presents believing men and believing women as allies of one another, sharing the responsibility of encouraging what is right and resisting what is wrong. This is a picture of a community in which moral responsibility is not assigned exclusively to men. That does not mean that every leadership position is automatically identical for men and women, nor does it settle every question of political authority. But it does challenge the sweeping idea that leadership, responsibility and public influence are inherently masculine qualities.
Beyond the Private-Public Divide
Perhaps the most useful lesson from the Prophetic model is that the sharp division between ‘private woman’ and ‘public woman’ is not particularly helpful. A Muslim woman can be deeply committed to her family and still have a meaningful public role. She can be modest without being invisible. She can be intellectually accomplished without becoming disconnected from faith. She can serve her family without being told that she has no responsibilities beyond it. And she can serve society without being made to feel that public contribution somehow makes her less feminine or less religious.
While these concepts are understood the whole perspective itself may change. Instead of asking, “Can women participate?”, we might ask, “What kind of participation serves the purposes of the community?” Instead of asking, “Should a woman be visible in society?”, we might ask, “How can she contribute with dignity, competence and integrity?” And instead of assuming that family and public life are opposing worlds, we can ask how both can be held together responsibly.
The Prophetic model does not present women as a homogeneous group, nor does it demand that every woman follow the same path. The challenge for Muslim societies today is not to reproduce the seventh century mechanically, nor to imitate contemporary western models uncritically. It is to recover the principles that animated the first Muslim community: faith, modesty, responsibility, knowledge, dignity, service and justice.
When these principles are comprehended, the image of the Muslim woman changes. It will be understood that she is actually not waiting to be given permission to participate in societal affairs but she is already a morally responsible member of the nation. Perhaps that is what it means to rediscover the Prophetic model: not to create a new Muslim woman, but to remember the woman who was already there and to recover the dignity, agency, knowledge, responsibility and social contribution that were visible in the women of the first generation.
References:
- Tahreer al Mar’ah fi Asr al Risalah (The Liberation of Women in the Era of Prophetic Message) by Abd Al Halim Abu Shuqqah
- Women around the Messenger by Muhammad Ali Qutb
- Ahadith – sunnah.com



0 Comments