The author is a public speaker and public policy scholar pursuing a Master’s in Public Policy, with a background in Political Science from University of Delhi’s PGDAV College.
Freedom of speech is the soul of Indian democracy. Since Independence, the right to freedom of speech and expression has been given utmost value, and its importance is felt in every heart and soul of the citizens. Without any hindrance based on the grounds of religion, caste, creed, gender or any political ideology, everyone is given equality in terms of speech and expression.
The Rise of “Digital Exile”
For many days now, a word has become a burning topic for debate, and that is “Digital Exile” — that is, deleting or removing selected media which is criticising the government.
Through various measures, or with the assistance of various IT Acts, Digital Exile takes place, which is devastating for democracy. Earlier, the Supreme Court said that the government is entitled to give reason for removing media digitally, but the government, even after the procedural rule of Rule 16, is removing media against it despite giving no reason.
The right to freedom of speech has become a dead letter with no aliveness in it. It has just remained a word with no practical implications, factually. Irrespective of whatever the government is doing, everyone is entitled in a democracy to express their views, no matter if it is in favour or against citizens.
No state has been given power so impactful that it starts violating people’s freedom of speech and expression.
According to reports, in 2014 the accounts blocked for criticising the government were 470, but in 2021 it rose to up to 9,800. Such accounts, politically criticising the government, have been blocked.
A huge increase in number is generating a deep question towards media.
Media, which is considered the fourth pillar of the Indian Constitution, sounds impactful on paper but vague in practice. These phrases are entitled to be called a paper tiger.
A Silent Judiciary
Digital Exile by the government raises concern not only for democracy but also for the working of the Supreme Court.
This ensures arbitrary and authoritative rule of the government and puts a deep question on the judiciary and judicial review.
The Supreme Court, which has the utmost power to question or to check arbitrary actions of the government, is another paper tiger. The Supreme Court now has an ineffective presence and power, as it remains silent on the authoritative actions of the government.
The Supreme Court, just like the media, has become another passive acquiescence, or silent spectator, which remains silent on the authoritative actions of the government without even saying or realising its own worth or power.
Since Independence, India is viewed as a freedom-based democracy where citizens can criticise the government when it goes against them; the Indian polity books and preamble view India as having acquired freedom of speech and expression, but it is just another paper tiger.
It is just a word left to be used in designing or in making a good image of Indian democracy in the global context.
Where Does This Leave Democracy?
Recently, India ranked 157th in freedom of the press out of 180 countries, even below Pakistan, Nepal and Bangladesh. Even our neighbours are above us in press freedom.
Freedom of the press is itself the soul of democracy and the biggest reason for democracy’s existence; the 157th rank states that democracy is in jeopardy.
The menace to democracy is created by political elites who, in the name of democracy, religion and caste, are in reality jeopardising the soul of Indian democracy.
Media is the biggest paper tiger left in Indian democracy, another spectator sharing a common identity with the Supreme Court in hiding the truth and malfeasance of the government.
Violation of freedom of speech leads to precariousness of freedom and democracy, not only for citizens, but for the nation’s future and India’s image globally.
Even a neighbouring country like Nepal is ranked 87th in freedom of the press, which India should follow.
Freedom of speech is the most essential right of citizens, just like the right to life and to vote. One must criticise the government or its actions if the actions taken by the government are unethical, but if this freedom is curtailed or violated, this will lead to a snare situation in the future of India.
The leader is elected by the people, for the people and of the people, and if people are not able to express or speak their views freely, then how can India be called a democracy?
Democracy doesn’t only mean the rule of the people but also understanding the ethical and unethical acts of the government, promoting freedom of speech and expression without the fear of any leader, voting for the deserving candidate, and living without fear.
Another name for democracy is citizens’ freedom to live without fear, but unfortunately, this is another paper tiger, which exists with no aliveness, or is powerless.
If this persists, democracy will be called the next new form of dictatorship, where the country has democracy (which is a paper tiger), but in reality the freedom and rights are curtailed, masking dictatorship in the name of democracy.
The worst part is that neither media nor the judiciary is realising the dreadful impact of its silence, which will hinder Indian democracy in future.


0 Comments