Category : LEGAL DESK

The author is a renowned journalist

Constitution Bench Verdict and Federal Principles

The verdict of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in the Presidential Reference case is a severe blow to the federal principles of the Indian Constitution.

A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, comprising the Chief Justice of India, B. R. Gavai, and Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P. S. Narasimha, and Atul S. Chandurkar, on Thursday, 20 November 2025, held that the directions issued in the Supreme Court’s 11 April 2025 judgment, which set timelines for Governors and the President to grant assent to Bills passed by legislatures, were incorrect and violative of the principle of separation of powers.

Presidential Reference Under Article 143

The judgment was delivered on a reference made by the President of India, Droupadi Murmu, under Article 143(1) of the Constitution of India. This provision empowers the President to seek the Supreme Court’s legal opinion on matters of public importance.

The Presidential Reference followed the 11 April 2025 judgment delivered by a Bench of Justices J. B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan in State of Tamil Nadu v. The Governor of Tamil Nadu & Anr.

That order categorically held that Governors must act within a reasonable time and that constitutional silence could not be employed to scuttle the democratic process.

April 2025 Judgment and Governor’s Conduct

It is true, as noted in the April judgment, that the Constitution of India does not prescribe a specific time limit for the discharge of functions by the Governor under Article 200. However, the Court clarified that this Article cannot be interpreted to mean that a Governor is free to sit indefinitely on Bills presented to him and thereby block the functioning of the legislature.

Consequently, the Supreme Court laid down timelines for the actions of Governors. This was particularly significant in view of the conduct of the Tamil Nadu Governor, R. N. Ravi, who, acting almost like a Super Chief Minister, sat over Bills passed by the Legislature for more than two years.

Directions Issued to Governors

The Supreme Court issued the following directions, which were welcomed by Opposition-ruled State governments, especially Tamil Nadu, Kerala, and West Bengal, which have been repeatedly troubled by Governors appointed by the National Democratic Alliance (NDA)-led Union Government:

  1. In cases where assent to a Bill is withheld, the Governor must return the Bill along with a message within a maximum period of one month.
  2. In cases where assent is withheld after reconsideration, the Governor must return the Bill with a message within a maximum period of three months.
  3. In cases where the Bill is reserved for the consideration of the President, the Governor must make such reservation within a maximum period of three months.
  4. When a Bill is presented again after reconsideration, the Governor must grant assent forthwith, subject to a maximum period of one month, in accordance with the first proviso to Article 200.

The Court further held that failure to comply with these timelines would render the Governor’s inaction subject to judicial review.

With regard to the President’s powers under Article 201, the Supreme Court held that her decision-making would also be subject to judicial review and must ordinarily be exercised within three months.

Constitution Bench Overturns April Judgment

While overturning the April judgment, the Constitution Bench observed that the discharge of functions under Articles 200 and 201 by the Governors and the President is generally non-justiciable. However, judicial intervention is permissible in cases of inordinate and unexplained delay, to be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

At the same time, the Bench made it clear that Governors cannot act as Super Chief Ministers and that there cannot be two executives in a State.

Constitutional Position Under Article 200

In this context, it is pertinent to examine Article 200 of the Constitution, which governs the Governor’s power to grant or withhold assent to Bills.

When a Bill is presented to the Governor:

“The Governor shall declare either that he assents to the Bill or that he withholds assent therefrom or that he reserves the Bill for the consideration of the President.”

The proviso further states:

“Provided that the Governor may, as soon as possible after the presentation to him of the Bill for assent, return the Bill, if it is not a Money Bill, together with a message requesting that the House or Houses reconsider the Bill or any specified provisions thereof… and if the Bill is passed again by the House or Houses with or without amendment and presented to the Governor for assent, the Governor shall not withhold assent therefrom.”

No Discretion in Grant of Assent

Thus, the Constitution of India leaves no scope for discretion on the part of the Governor in granting assent once a Bill is passed again by the Legislature.

This position has been clearly explained by Wade and Phillips: Constitutional Law, Third Edition (pp. 93, 96):

“In law the Governor can refuse to give assent to a Bill… But in the form of government set up under the Constitution, it would be politically impossible for a Governor to refuse assent to a Bill after it has been passed by the Legislature, because he acts in this matter, as in all public matters, on the advice of his Cabinet.”

The authors compare this position to that of the British monarch, whose veto power has fallen into disuse since the reign of Queen Anne, owing to the principle of ministerial responsibility.

Reservation of Bills for Presidential Consideration

However, the power vested in the Governor to reserve a Bill for the consideration of the President is discretionary. In exercising this power, the Governor acts as an important link between the Union and the States, enabling the Union to exercise a degree of control over State legislative activity.

Historical examples include:

  • The Kerala Education Bill, 1957, and the Kerala Agrarian Reform Bill, 1957, which were reserved for Presidential consideration and later returned for reconsideration.
  • The Madhya Pradesh Panchayat Bill, 1961, which was returned on the ground that certain provisions were undemocratic and contrary to the Directive Principles of State Policy.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *