Aura has started “The Heart’s Clinic” as a new regular column, where a trained psychologist will answer your queries. We encourage our readers to send their queries to [email protected]. Full confidentality will be maintained.

Zulekha Shakoor Rajani is a Counselling and Spiritual Psychologist specializing in Islamic Psychology, with over 8,500 hours of clinical practice. She serves as the Clinical Director and Head of the Department of Islamic Psychology (Research, Training & Psychoeducation) at Ummeed Counselling Centre, a unit of Ummeed Deaddiction and Rehabilitation Centre, Bengaluru. She holds an M.Sc. in Psychology and a Diploma in Islamic Psychology from Cambridge Muslim College (Cambridge, UK), with advanced training through the Khalil Center (Istanbul, Türkiye), Avicenna Academy (Indonesia), and Al-Balagh Academy (UK). She is a Research Fellow, Supervisor, and Facilitator at Al-Balagh Academy (UK), a Facilitator at The Quran Institute (Al-Madad Outreach, UK), and an Executive Advisory Member of ISIP. A TEDx Speaker on bringing the soul back into mainstream conversations on mental health, she was recognized among the AIMDC 40 Under 40 Leaders (2025) for her contributions to faith-integrated mental healthcare.

Question 1

“I told someone at the masjid I was struggling, and she said I just needed more imaan.”

A few months ago, I finally gathered the courage to tell someone at the masjid that I had been struggling emotionally. Instead of listening, she told me I just needed more imaan, should stop overthinking, and pray more. I left feeling ashamed, as though my struggles meant my faith wasn’t strong enough. Since then, I’ve found myself avoiding religious people because I’m afraid of being judged again, but then I feel guilty for pulling away. Part of me even feels resentful, and I hate feeling that way. How do I stop resenting them? The hardest part is that I feel this experience has affected my relationship with Allah, and I feel guilty for even saying that. How do I move forward?

Sister, 27, Bangalore

Answer

Before anything else, I’m so sorry this was your experience. It takes courage to tell someone you’re struggling, especially within a faith community where you hope to find comfort and understanding. Instead, you left feeling unheard, dismissed, and wondering whether your struggles reflected something wrong with you. That is a painful place to be.

If it’s okay, I’d like to gently separate what you’re carrying into three different struggles, because I think they have become intertwined. The first is the assumption that conversation may have left behind, that your emotional struggles somehow reflect weak imaan or a deficiency in your faith. The second is the hurt, and perhaps even the resentment, that arose from being dismissed at a moment when you were vulnerable. The third is the fear that this experience has begun to colour your relationship with Allah and Islam itself. They are deeply connected, but they are not the same, and I think it helps to hold them apart for a moment.

Sometimes sincere people respond to another’s pain in ways that are unhelpful, not because they wish to hurt, but because they do not know how to carry someone else’s struggles. That is a human shortcoming, not a reflection of our deen.

Think of it this way: if you were to visit a hospital and encounter a doctor who was dismissive or a nurse who lacked compassion, you might leave feeling hurt. Your pain would be real, and what happened would be wrong. But you would not conclude that medicine itself had failed you. The failure would belong to those who did not practise it well, not to the science of healing itself. In much the same way, some Muslims may fall short of the mercy, wisdom, and compassion that

Islam teaches. Their shortcomings should not become the yardstick by which we measure Allah or His religion.

Let’s begin with the first struggle, the assumption that your emotional struggles reflect weak imaan. I want to gently challenge that idea, because it is not what our faith teaches.

Imaan is not the absence of pain, fear, grief, or anxiety. It is the trust that keeps turning back to Allah through them. It is the certainty that He is with you, even when your heart feels heavy. It is not measured by whether you struggle, but by whom you continue to turn towards in the midst of that struggle.

Strong faith was never a promise of an easy inner life. Prophets grieved. Yaqub (AS) wept for his lost son until his eyes turned white with sorrow (Surah Yusuf, 12:84), and Allah still described his patience as beautiful and honoured him as a prophet. The Prophet (S.A.W.) himself regularly sought refuge from al-hamm wal-hazan, anxiety and grief (Sahih al-Bukhari 6369). He (S.A.W.) would not have taught his ummah a supplication for a feeling he expected us never to have.

So no, struggling in itself is not evidence that your faith is deficient. Faith does not always remove the weight we carry. Often, it is what enables us to carry it without losing hope in the One who helps us through it.

When we look at the life of the Prophet (S.A.W.), we find a different model from the one you encountered. Search the seerah for a single occasion when someone came to him in distress and he made them feel small for it or dismissed it. You will not find one. When Abu Bakr (RA) became afraid in the cave, the Prophet (S.A.W.) did not correct his fear. He reassured it: “Do not grieve; indeed Allah is with us.” (Surah at-Tawbah, 9:40). When his own son Ibrahim passed away, he (S.A.W.) wept and said: “The eyes shed tears and the heart grieves, but we do not say except what pleases our Lord.” (Sahih al-Bukhari 1303). His life teaches us that faith and emotion are not opposites. A believer can have a heart full of imaan and still know sorrow, anxiety, or fear.

The Prophet (S.A.W.) also instructed those who would carry this religion after him: “Make things easy and do not make them difficult; give glad tidings and do not drive people away.” (Sahih al-Bukhari 69; Sahih Muslim 1734). Notice what is being cautioned against. Not wrong belief, but the driving away of a heart. Allah reminds us of the same principle: “And had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you.” (Surah Al Imran, 3:159). Gentleness has always been among the clearest signs of prophetic guidance. Abdullah ibn Amr (RA) described the Prophet (S.A.W.) as never being coarse or vulgar in speech, and reported that he (S.A.W.) would say: “The best among you are the best in character.” (Sahih al-Bukhari 6035).

Now let’s turn to the second, your hurt and resentment. If someone’s words left you feeling unseen or diminished, it is understandable that you withdrew. It does not necessarily mean she intended harm. Most likely, she was reaching for the only comfort she knew.

It may also help to remember that many sincere Muslims are still learning how to think about mental health. As these conversations have become more common, some people worry that ordinary human emotions are being medicalised, or that every difficult experience is being labelled a condition. There is some truth in that concern. We do sometimes see everyday struggles being over-pathologised. But the opposite mistake is just as harmful: assuming that every emotional struggle is simply a sign of weak imaan or insufficient reliance upon Allah.

Genuine psychological suffering exists, just as genuine spiritual struggles exist, and our tradition has room to acknowledge both.

Most of us do this without realising it. When we see someone in pain, we offer the thing that once carried us through our own. For many Muslims, that is dua, remembrance of Allah, and reliance upon Him, and those are beautiful teachings of our faith. But alongside reminding, our tradition also teaches us to listen, to show compassion, and to make space for another person’s pain and gently walk them through it. Sometimes, when reassurance arrives before understanding, even sincere words can leave someone feeling unseen.

As for the resentment you feel, do not be alarmed by its presence. Feelings often arise before we have any chance to guide them. Resentment often tells us that something in us was hurt, unseen, or left unprotected. What matters is not that you feel it, but that it does not become the final story. In time, with Allah’s help, healing may allow that resentment to soften into compassion, for yourself, and perhaps even for the person who did not know how to respond to your pain.

You also do not owe your struggles to everyone. Trust is earned, and choosing carefully whom you confide in is wisdom, not withdrawal. Seek out people who listen with compassion and guide you well: a knowledgeable teacher, a mentor, or a qualified counsellor. And if what you are carrying has become heavy or persistent, know that there is no contradiction between seeking treatment and relying upon Allah. The Prophet (S.A.W.) taught us: “Allah has not sent down a disease except that He has sent down its cure.” (Jami at-Tirmidhi 2038).

Finally, the third, your relationship with Allah and Islam. What happened to you was painful, but it does not have to define your faith. Human beings sometimes fall short of reflecting the beauty of this religion, not because the religion lacks mercy, but because we are all imperfect in how we embody it. Your relationship with Allah is far greater than any one conversation, and He knows the pain you carried away that day, even if no one else did.

Perhaps one day, in sha Allah, someone will come to you carrying a burden much like your own. Your experience may allow you to offer the gentleness you once needed. Sometimes Allah allows us to experience hardship so that we can become a mercy for someone else.

What happened to you was a painful human experience, not a reflection of Allah’s mercy, nor the essence of His religion. There is an important difference. As you gently begin to separate the two, I pray you find your way back: not just to a place or a community, but to the closeness with Allah that has always been waiting for you.

1 Comment

  1. jilislotphlogin

    Love how easy it is to get into the action here. No complicated steps, just straight to the fun. I always use jilislotphlogin for my daily spins.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *