Category : MEDIA WATCH

The author is a veteran and widely-published journalist.

Constitutional Protection of Press Freedom

The Supreme Court of India and several High Courts have repeatedly held that freedom of expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution is a fundamental right and cannot be suppressed. However, the Income Tax Department of the Union government does not seem to share this view.
In Romesh Thapar vs State of Madras (1950), the Supreme Court ruled that the press plays a significant role in informing the public and promoting democratic values. Therefore, any attempt to curtail the freedom of the press would violate the right to freedom of expression.

Denial of Philanthropic Status to The Reporters’ Collective

Despite this, on January 27, 2025, the Income Tax authorities refused to extend philanthropic status to The Reporters’ Collective (TRC), an association of journalists consistently publishing reports critical of the Union government led by Narendra Modi. The authorities asserted that “journalism does not serve any public purpose.”
A recent report by TRC, titled Inside Modi Government’s War Room to Whitewash Global Indices, alleged that the Modi government had been lobbying to change methodologies to inflate India’s ranking in global indices.
TRC, which has been operating as a registered non-profit in India since July 2021, will no longer be exempt from paying income tax due to the revocation of its non-profit status. As a result, all donations received by TRC will now be taxed, and donors will lose their tax rebate benefits, as TRC will be treated as a commercial organization.

Tax Implications of Non-Profit Status Revocation

Organizations registered under Section 12AB of the Income Tax Act are exempt from income tax on donations received, and donors also benefit from tax exemptions. However, with the IT Department’s decision to revoke TRC’s non-profit status, both past and future donations can now be taxed.
Under Section 115TD, any accumulations an institution has made before the cancellation of its registration can also be taxed. When non-profit registration is revoked, the organization is subject to tax at the maximum marginal rate, which ranges from 30% to 42% depending on income levels.

Investigative Reporting and Government Criticism

In January 2024, TRC reported that in 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi attempted “backdoor negotiations with the Finance Commission to cut tax funds allocated to states.” TRC has also covered issues related to women’s safety, environmental concerns, and the ethnic conflict in Manipur. Additionally, it has published investigative reports on the Union Government’s Electoral Bonds Scheme and the business operations of the Adani Group.

Political Reactions to the IT Department’s Action

Several opposition leaders have condemned the misuse of the IT Department to suppress government criticism. Congress leader P. Chidambaram tweeted, “One more building block of freedom was knocked down when the Income Tax Department cancelled the non-profit status of The Reporters’ Collective.”
Congress MP Randeep Singh Surjewala accused the Modi government of being “inimical to independent media and hating the free press.” Former TMC MP Jawhar Sircar stated that the Prime Minister had “unleashed Income Tax hounds to terrorize the media that exposes his corruption and high-handedness.”

Precedents of Tax Exemption Revocation

In June 2024, the IT Department also revoked the tax exemption status of Aman Biradari, an NGO led by human rights activist Harsh Mander, and canceled its registration under Section 12AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Definition of “Charitable Purpose” Under Tax Law

Section 2(15) of the Income Tax Act defines “charitable purpose” as including:

  • Relief of the poor
  • Education
  • Yoga
  • Medical relief
  • Preservation of the environment
  • Preservation of monuments or objects of artistic or historic interest
  • Advancement of any other object of general public utility

The first six categories are inherently charitable. The seventh, “advancement of any other object of general public utility,” is relevant to TRC’s case. However, the Act does not clearly define “general public utility.” Generally, an activity qualifies if it has a worthy purpose and benefits a sufficiently large section of the public.

Journalism as a Public Utility

TRC’s main objectives include education and public utility. Its activities—publishing news, conducting research, promoting journalism, and providing training—are non-profit in nature.
Philanthro-journalism inherently serves the public interest. Responsible journalism builds an informed citizenry and acts as a “watchdog” in a democracy. Thus, it should be considered an activity of “general public utility.”

Arbitrary Exercise of Power

Despite this, the Commissioner’s order revoking TRC’s non-profit status does not indicate that the association is engaged in commercial activities for profit. The decision was made arbitrarily, without proper application of mind, by simply declaring that journalism lacks public utility.

Legal Challenge and Court Intervention

On February 10, the Delhi High Court, hearing a writ petition filed by The Reporters’ Collective challenging the IT Commissioner’s order, directed the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal to resolve the issue expeditiously.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *