The author is a Ph.D scholar in Political Science
Introduction
Nowadays, in the online space — particularly within the educational content niche — there has been an upsurge in the pop-culturification of various academic disciplines: pop psychology, pop spirituality, and so on. Popular history has therefore received the same treatment. HistoryTok, HistoryTube, HistoryGram, and History Twitter are all prominent examples. Short-form content marvelling at quirky historical fun facts, or dramatising a particular historical incident, frequently goes viral, prompting thousands of comments. On the longer-form side, there has been a growing trend of pop historians — individuals who may hold some form of educational qualification, though not necessarily in the subject they lecture, podcast, and deliver public speeches on, namely history.
Arguably, both types of content carry some positive value: they generate public interest in history as a subject and, in the case of pop historians especially, render what is often considered an academically demanding subject accessible to a general audience. However, perusing the comment sections of such videos frequently reveals troubling downsides. At best, the way history is presented in this format results in the misrepresentation of historical accuracy and nuance. At worst, it intentionally or inadvertently becomes fodder for popular misconceptions, validating parochial narratives that are being deliberately promoted by political interests.
Pervasive anti-intellectualism
This phenomenon reflects a larger trend of anti-intellectualism permeating popular discourse, particularly in the Indian context. There is a widespread mistrust of academic figures, with many perceiving them as biased against the majority community and as advancing a worldview that challenges a simpler, more comfortable understanding of the past. Many people are unwilling to sit with complexity — to approach history through varied methodological perspectives, to move beyond false communal binaries, to reconcile seemingly contradictory ideas, or to draw meaningful distinctions between different historical eras. This creates fertile ground for figures such as right-wing pop historians, who cultivate the trust of this constituency. Yet such figures are rarely immune to the very same critiques they level at academia — critiques that were seldom made in good faith to begin with. Nor is the problem confined to the right wing alone. Many prominent names in the popular history space, across different ideological orientations — perhaps owing to a lack of formal disciplinary training — inadvertently ignore the historical method, fuel problematic tendencies such as grand narratives, or fall into traps like methodological nationalism.
Before examining each of these drawbacks in detail, it is worth understanding what is at stake when the historical method is sidelined. What the anti-intellectualism wave consistently misses about academia is that its rigour and methodological standards serve a vital function: every argument must be substantiated by evidence, data, previously established research, existing literature, and academic consensus. Broad, sweeping, unsubstantiated claims are therefore difficult to sustain within academic discourse.
As far as history is concerned, the historical method is among the most important of these methodological frameworks — one that no individual who genuinely claims the title of historian can afford to ignore.
What is the historical method?
The historical method refers to the framework historians use to research and present evidence about the past. It involves five core steps: gathering primary and secondary sources; external criticism (testing authenticity) and internal criticism (testing credibility); corroborating sources against each other; interpreting evidence to construct a narrative; and citing sources transparently so findings can be challenged or built upon. Underpinning the method are three key principles: scepticism toward sources, understanding events in their proper context, and acknowledging the limits of available evidence. The 19th-century German historian Leopold von Ranke is often credited with systematising it, with his famous goal of describing the past “as it actually was”. Later, the French Annales school broadened history beyond political events to include social structures, geography, and long-term trends. Postmodern critiques since the 1970s have challenged the idea that historians can achieve objective truth at all, arguing that all history involves narrative choices shaped by the historian’s own position. Most contemporary historians occupy a middle ground — acknowledging subjectivity while still adhering to rigorous evidentiary standards.
Together, these practices distinguish rigorous historical scholarship from mere opinion or storytelling.
Our contexts
The Babri Masjid/Ayodhya narrative is a strong example of a problematic history popularised by ignoring the historical method.
A widely circulated claim holds that the Babri Masjid, built in 1528 under Babur, was constructed after demolishing a grand Ram temple marking Ram’s exact birthplace. This became politically explosive, culminating in the mosque’s demolition in 1992.
The primary textual source, the Baburnama, is actually silent on any temple demolition. The claim rests substantially on later colonial-era accounts, particularly a report by British official P. Carnegy in 1870, and contested archaeological interpretations. The ASI excavation report (2003) was itself disputed, with many scholars arguing its conclusions were predetermined rather than evidence-driven.
Colonial administrators hardened what were originally ambiguous historical claims into an emotionally charged “fact,” framing Indian history as a civilisational Hindu-Muslim conflict — lending institutional respectability to a narrative that rigorous evidence did not support. Communal propagandists subsequently continued circulating this version long after mainstream scholarship had complicated it, with serious consequences for public life.
A proper application of the historical method — corroborating across Sanskrit, Persian, and colonial sources and subjecting archaeology to genuine peer scrutiny — reveals a far more uncertain picture than the popular narrative admits.
Ultimately, a centuries-old historical monument, indeed a piece of this nation’s heritage, was levelled to the ground amid communal slogans rending the air, and for decades afterwards, utilised as a symbolism/justification for communal riots against the minority community, and even to justify future planned demolition of other historic mosques and ‘Muslim’ monuments.
When the historical method is ignored, the consequences can be disastrous.
Another major problem with popular history discourse is the tendency of methodological nationalism prevalent in almost all major popular history figures in the Indian context, regardless of ideological orientation. Methodological nationalism refers to the tendency among researchers and academics to default to the nation-state as the primary lens through which society is understood, without critically examining whether this is the most appropriate framework.
Consider a river analysed only within a single stretch, with no attention paid to its source or destination. The river does not stop at an arbitrarily chosen boundary, and neither do most social phenomena. The core problem is that the modern world is deeply interconnected. People, capital, ideas, and social problems traverse borders continuously. When researchers treat individual countries as self-contained units, significant dimensions of social reality are obscured.
Why does this matter? The assumptions researchers bring to their work fundamentally shape the questions they ask and the conclusions they reach. Unreflectively treating the nation-state as the natural unit of analysis risks producing research that is partial or misleading — one that reinforces national narratives rather than engaging with the more complex, interconnected realities beneath them.
In conclusion
In short, borders are a human construction, and social reality does not consistently conform to them.
Therefore, this urge to portray India as a singular, unified, and overarching historical civilisation misses significant nuances on multiple fronts. It projects contemporary political anxieties onto the past in a manner that does not hold up under anything beyond surface-level analysis. More importantly, such grand narratives of Indian history tend to be disproportionately focused on one region — most often north India — to the exclusion of other geographical areas, as well as the diverse communities that make up the subcontinent. Particularly histories of those long marginalised from mainstream narratives — communities from the south and north-east, women, lower castes, Dalits, Adivasis, and forest-dwelling peoples — representing, in effect, the histories of the majority.
Another problematic aspect of popular history is the issue of anachronistic interpretation — reading the past through the assumptions and values of the present. Judging, for instance, medieval agrarian societies by the standards of modern democratic governance distorts rather than illuminates historical reality. This problem is not confined to popular history books or online content; it has increasingly found its way into formal textbook revisions, meaning that historically unsound narratives are being transmitted to children as established fact. The consequences for social harmony are significant — younger generations shaped by distorted or communally charged historical narratives carry those assumptions into adult civic life.
The solution, however, is not to make history less rigorous, but to make rigorous history more accessible. The historical method need not remain confined to academic journals. Public awareness programmes, documentary media, accessible long-form journalism, and thoughtfully produced educational content can all serve as vehicles for translating sound historical scholarship to a general audience. The goal is not simplification at the cost of accuracy, but communication that respects both the complexity of the past and the intelligence of the public. Accessibility and rigour are not opposing values — the challenge lies in bringing them into productive alignment.
References:
Popular History versus Professional Historians: The Fight Against Distortion – The Wire by Amar Farooqui. Jan 29th, 2026.
DID YOU KNOW ?
India has one
of the oldest continuous literary traditions
From ancient oral traditions to written texts in Sanskrit, Tamil, Persian, and Arabic, the Indian subcontinent has preserved knowledge across thousands of years—making it one of the richest literary cultures in the world.

![HS[ Beyond the Grand Narrative_ ]](https://auramag.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/HS-Beyond-the-Grand-Narrative_-.jpg)
The customer support team is very helpful and answered all my questions in minutes. It is rare to find such good service. Thanks bdkk77