The author is a renowned journalist.
A Troubling Judicial Intervention
As a reporter who has witnessed the continuous erosion of academic freedoms in our educational institutions, one can conclude that the Supreme Court’s reaction to the publication of a Class VIII textbook containing a chapter on judicial corruption, published by the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), has been too harsh.
A three-judge bench of the Supreme Court led by the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, without even issuing a notice to the Government of India or the NCERT, on 26 February 2026 imposed a complete ban on the publication, reprinting, and dissemination of the book. The court also ordered the immediate seizure of all physical and digital copies.
The Supreme Court described the inclusion of this topic as a “calculated move to undermine the institution” and a “deep-rooted conspiracy.”
The matter came to light on February 24 when The Indian Express, Delhi edition, published a report with the headline: “NCERT’s new Class 8 book lists ‘corruption in judiciary’, ‘massive backlog’ as challenges.”
“Corruption in judiciary” formed part of a chapter on “The Role of the Judiciary in Our Society.” The section listed “corruption at various levels of the judiciary” and “massive backlog… on account of multiple reasons such as lack of an adequate number of judges, complicated legal procedures, and poor infrastructure” as among the challenges faced by the judicial system.
The old text described the role of the judiciary, the importance of an independent judiciary, the structure of the courts, and access to them. There was no reference to corruption. However, it did refer to the inordinate delay in Indian courts that causes denial of justice to common people because “justice delayed is justice denied.”
The new chapter lists the pending cases in the Supreme Court as 81,000; in High Courts as 62,40,000; and in district and subordinate courts as 4,70,00,000.
The section on corruption in the judiciary, the Indian Express report said, stated that judges are bound by a code of conduct that governs not only their behaviour in court but also how they conduct themselves outside it. It also described the judiciary’s internal mechanism to maintain accountability and an established procedure for receiving complaints through the Centralised Public Grievance Redress and Monitoring System (CPGRAMS). The chapter added that over 1,600 complaints were received between 2017 and 2021.
In cases where the allegations are serious, Parliament can take action and remove a judge by passing a motion of impeachment. Such a motion is considered only after a proper enquiry, during which the judge is given a fair opportunity to present their side of the case, the new chapter added.
“Nevertheless, people do experience corruption at various levels of the judiciary. For the poor and disadvantaged, this can worsen the issue of access to justice. Hence efforts are constantly being made at the State and Union levels to build faith and increase transparency in the judicial system, including through the use of technology, and to take swift and decisive action against instances of corruption wherever they may arise,” the chapter added.
It also quoted former Chief Justice of India B. R. Gavai, who in July 2025 said:
“Sadly there have been instances of corruption and misconduct that have surfaced even within the judiciary. Such occurrences inevitably have a negative impact on public confidence, potentially eroding faith in the integrity of the system as a whole.”
“However, the path to rebuilding this trust lies in swift, decisive, and transparent action taken to address and resolve these issues… Any erosion of this confidence risks weakening the judiciary’s constitutional role as the ultimate arbiter of rights. Transparency and accountability are democratic virtues,” Gavai had added, according to the quote.
The Content of the Lesson
Following the discussion on “Why is an independent judiciary needed for justice?”, the lesson asks students to discuss two recent important rulings of the Supreme Court of India — one on the Electoral Bonds case and another on the amendment to the Information Technology Act, 2009.
The lesson states that in 2018 the Union government introduced Electoral Bonds to raise funds for political parties. The scheme facilitated individuals and companies to donate money anonymously to political parties.
Issued by banks, the electoral bonds could only be encashed by political parties that met certain criteria. However, the Supreme Court of India struck down the scheme as unconstitutional, maintaining that voters have a right to know who is funding political parties.
On the Information Technology Act, 2009, the Class VIII textbook explains that a few years after the Act was passed, the Union government amended the Act, adding a clause to prosecute and jail individuals for varying periods for posts made on the internet or social media.
In 2015, a law student challenged the amendment in the Supreme Court, arguing that it violated freedom of speech guaranteed by the Constitution, and the Supreme Court set it aside as unconstitutional. The lesson asks students to analyse the judgements in both cases in detail.
Concerns About Academic Freedom
While it is debatable whether Class VIII students are equipped to study and comment on such important constitutional issues, by no stretch of imagination can anyone hold the writers of such lessons in contempt of court.
The lesson in question actually quotes none other than former Chief Justice of India B. R. Gavai to substantiate the problem of corruption in the judiciary. One wonders how the Supreme Court could hold the words of a former Chief Justice of India in contempt.
Further, the Supreme Court on Wednesday, 11 March 2026, directed the Centre and the NCERT to exclude the three experts — Professor Michel Danino, educator Suparna Dewakar, and legal expert Alok Prasanna Kumar — from any role in preparing school curricula or holding any position in state bodies following their association with the Class VIII textbook. That such a ban has been imposed on three renowned academics without even hearing them obviously violates principles of natural justice.
One saving grace in the Supreme Court order in the textbook case is its observation that the judiciary was not averse to objective and legitimate criticism about its institutional functioning.
“If the judiciary, like any other institution, is suffering from deficiencies and if an expert committee highlights such deficiencies, it would be a welcome step, not only for the future generations of this nation, including future practitioners, but it would also open an avenue for present stakeholders to take necessary remedial steps,” the Supreme Court said.

If the judiciary, like any other institution, is suffering from deficiencies and if an expert committee highlights such deficiencies, it would be a welcome step, not only for the future generations of this nation, including future practitioners, but it would also open an avenue for present stakeholders to take necessary remedial steps,
– the Supreme Court said.


The app is so convenient. I can play my favorite games anywhere and anytime without any glitches. Download bet55apk today!