The author is a renowned journalist.
Much water has flowed under the Yamuna bridge in Delhi since the Union Government, led by Narendra Modi, repealed the three controversial farm laws in Parliament on 29 November 2021, following more than a year of farmer’s protests on the city’s borders.
More than 750 farmers were killed during the farmer’s protests due to road accidents, bad weather, and natural causes. The protests ended after the Union government repealed the farm laws and promised to introduce a bill guaranteeing minimum support prices (MSP) for various farm products.
The NDA government is entering its third term, but the MSP bill has yet to be implemented. The government’s other promises, such as doubling farmers’ incomes by 2022 and implementing the 2004 M.S. Swaminathan Commission on Farmers recommendations, are also in question.
The impasse regarding Indian farmers’ long-standing grievances led to the 70-year-old farmer leader Jagjit Singh Dallewal, Convener of the Samyukta Kisan Morcha (non-political) (SKM ), starting a fast until his death on 26 November 2024 at the Punjab—Haryana border.
Besides guaranteed MSP, the farmers are demanding debt waiver, pension for farmers and farm labourers and no increase in the electricity tariff. A month after he sat on fast unto death, Dallewal, who is suffering from cancer told the media, “ Seven lakh farmers of this country have committed suicide due to debt. It is necessary to save farmers, therefore I am sitting here. I am not under anyone’s pressure .”
Following the 2020 -21 protest against farm laws Kerala, Punjab, Chhattisgarh Rajasthan, Delhi and West Bengal passed resolutions against farm laws and three states, Punjab, Chattisgarh and Rajasthan passed counter legislation in their respective State legislatures. Still, none of the counter legislation was signed into law by the state governors, who lately only do the bidding of the union government.
Farmer bodies agitating for farmers’ demands, the Kisan Mazdoor Morcha (KMM ) and Samyukta Kisan Morcha ( Non-political ), the two umbrella bodies spearheading the farmers’ agitation, are camping at Shambhu-Ambaala and Khanauri-Jind on the inter state-boundary after being stopped from entering Haryana.
On the 37th day of Dallewal’s fast, KMM coordinator Sarwan Singh Pandher said the farmers will continue the struggle until their demands are met. He added that the dates for the Delhi march will be announced very soon.
One hundred and one farmers attempted to restart their foot march from Punjab to Delhi on December 6, 8, and 14. However, the Haryana government erected massive barricades, which halted the march.
At the same time, the Samyukta Kisan Morcha, the umbrella organisation of some 500 farmers’ organisations, has turned down the invitation to discuss the matter extended by the high-powered Supreme Court committee. The committee, headed by a former High Court judge, Justice Nawab Singh, had invited the SKM to attend its meeting on Friday, January 3rd, 2025.
“The SKM in principle does not accept intervention of the Court because the farmers are fighting on policy issues with the Union government and hence the court has no role to play. In this context the SKM expresses its inability to accept the invitation for the discussion by the SC-appointed High Powered Committee”, the SKM said in a statement.
Commenting on Jagjit Singh Dallewal’s indefinite hunger strike, Union Agriculture Minister Shiv Raj Singh Chohan said in New Delhi on Wednesday that the Union government will abide by the Supreme Court’s directions. The Supreme Court is looking into the matter. We will accept whatever decision the apex court takes,” the Minister maintained.
The Supreme Court clarified on Thursday, 2 January, that its direction to provide medical help and hospitalisation to farmer leader Jagjit Singh Dhaliwal wasn’t aimed at breaking his fast. A bench of Justices Suryakant and Sudhanshu Dhulia said that Dallewal could continue his hunger strike under medical supervision.
The Supreme Court expressed its displeasure at the Punjab government’s deliberate attempt to give the impression that the court has been pressuring Dallewal to end his fast unto death.
“Our directions were not to break his fast. We only said that his health be taken care of and that he could continue his peaceful protest even when he is hospitalised. You have to persuade him from this angle, “ the bench told Punjab Advocate General Gurminder Singh. In other words, the Supreme Court’s only concern was Dallewal’s well-being, not the farmer’s plight.
The Court further said: “Shifting to the hospital does not mean he will not continue his fast. There are medical facilities that will ensure that no harm is caused to his life. THIS IS OUR ONLY CONCERN. His life is precious as a farmers’ leader.”
Now, the question is who will solve the farmers‘ problem. No solution is possible until the Union government, in consultation with the state governments, negotiates with the farmers’ representatives. Under the present circumstances, the Union Agriculture Minister’s waiting for directions from the Supreme Court will not yield any result because farmers’ Unions have rejected Court intervention.

Pariksha Pe Charcha wins over National Talent Search Examination
By Joseph Maliakan

The National Talent Search Examination, conducted by the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) to select 2000 schoolchildren from all over the country for scholarships, has been abandoned. Instead, the scheme has been replaced with Pariksha Pe Charcha, an annual event at which Prime Minister Narendra Modi advises students on preparing for various examinations!
The National Scholarship Scheme, started by the Union Education Ministry in 1963, was the most sought-after scholarship scheme by school students in the country. The examination used to be held in two phases. In the first phase, the states screened the students. The NCERT and 2000 students examined those selected by the states who were awarded national scholarships yearly.

Class X students were eligible to take the national talent examination. Each student selected for the scholarship gets Rs.1,250 a month in Classes XI and XII. Each scholar receives Rs.2,000 a month at the undergraduate and postgraduate levels. The scholarship at the PhD level became equivalent to the value of the Junior Research Fellowship given by the University Grants Commission, Rs. 37,500 a month for five years.
The National Talent Examination was considered a real talent test for at least two decades after its introduction. However, with the introduction of more national-level tests for admission to engineering, medicine, management, and the CUET for admission to any undergraduate course, etc., and the mushrooming of coaching institutes, the effectiveness of the talent search has also been declining.
The Union Education Ministry asked NCERT to review the Scheme in 2021. The review committee submitted its report in September 2022. The report said that the influence of coaching institutes had reduced the effectiveness of the examination in locating real talent.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s novel educational programme of Pariksha Pe Charcha, an event at which Modi advises school children on easily tackling examinations, began in 2018-19. The PPC is normally held in January in Delhi during the winter when schoolchildren from various states and schools are brought in. Modi, the prime minister turned school teacher, answered select questions at the event. The Union Ministry of Education organises the event, and the Ministry meets the cost.
For the six PPCs held from 2018 to 202,4, the Union Education Ministry spent Rs.78.83 crores. In 2018-19: 4.93 crores, 2019-20 5.70 crores, 2020-21: 6 crores, 2021- 22 8.16 crores, 2022-23: 10 crores and 2023-24: 16 crores. In 2022-23, “ appreciation “ letters were sent to all the 38 lakh participants” who had registered on the PPC portal and watched the event online on Prime Minister Modi’s letterhead. The task undertaken by the National Book Trust cost Rs.28 crores, 17.6 crores more than the event! In MIn2023- 24, the Union Education Ministry sent the “ appreciation “ letters online,e saving scarce resources.
The last National Talent Search Examination for the year 2020-21. In December 2021, the NCERT issued a notice saying that the Talent Search Examination for 2021-22 had been “postponed “ due to administrative reasons. After that, the NCERT remained silent on the matter. In other words, the scheme sought after and benefitted ordinary students has been given a quiet burial.
The yearly expenditure on the NTS scholarship was around Rs.13 crores, three crores less than the Rs.16 crores spent on PPC in 2023-24. Now, the question is, can the PPC, a one-day event held in Delhi, institute for a scholarship scheme that has stood the test of time?
Prime Minister Modi has already published a book titled Exam Warriors, which contains all the wisdom available to humankind. The annual PPC event is a total waste of energy and time. To remove anxiety and tension before an examination, all one has to do is read Exam Warriors!
PPC aims to cultivate an environment that celebrates, encourages and enables each child to express their unique individuality fully. Further, the programme seeks to address the concerns and anxieties faced by students during exam times and provide them with guidance and motivation.
So far, there has been no attempt to systematically study the impact of PPC on the students who participated in the event. Academics and parents have described the event as a public relations event to “glorify “ Prime Minister Modi’s image.
Talking to the Telegraph, Ashok Agrawal, President of the All India Parents Association, said it was unfortunate that the Union government was spending huge amounts on a self-glorification programme like the PPC and discounting a national scholarship programme that benefited students.



0 Comments