Category : LEGAL DESK
Author : Qudsia Misbah

the Author is Qudsia Misbah, a student at SVKM’s NMIMS School of Law (Hyd.)

Introduction

This article sheds light on the ground-breaking decision in Rajeeb Kalita v. Union of India & Ors (2023), where the Supreme Court of India took a giant step toward ensuring dignity for all by expanding the meaning of Article 21—the right to life and personal liberty. The Court ruled that hygienic and accessible toilets in High Courts and Tribunals across the nation are not just facilities but fundamental rights. The case was brought to the forefront by Rajeeb Kalita, a dedicated advocate, who highlighted the poor state of washrooms on court premises. His petition underscored how this neglect disproportionately affected women, transgender persons, and persons with disabilities (PwD), depriving them of the dignity promised by the Constitution. In its decision, the Supreme Court didn’t merely address convenience; it affirmed that access to proper sanitation is essential to leading a dignified life. The Court drew inspiration from previous landmark rulings like Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India and National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India while also looking to global principles such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights. These references reinforced the idea that sanitation is vital to human rights and public health. To make these rights a reality, the Court issued a detailed plan. It directed the High Courts and State Governments/UTs to construct and maintain separate washrooms for men, women, transgender persons, and PwD. The guidelines also called for interim measures like mobile toilets, heritage-friendly upgrades for older court buildings, and stringent cleaning protocols. The ruling emphasised not just construction but also regular upkeep, user-friendly complaint systems, and transparent funding to ensure lasting improvements. This decision is more than just a legal milestone—it’s a reminder of the judiciary’s commitment to protecting the dignity and equality of every individual. By acknowledging the connection between justice, dignity, and access to basic facilities, the Supreme Court has set a progressive benchmark. This case isn’t just about infrastructure; it’s about humanity, fairness, and creating spaces where everyone, regardless of their identity, can feel respected and valued.

One of the major fundamental constitutional rights that has been constantly reviewed and expanded since its inception into the constitution is Article 21, the right to life and personal liberty. As held in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India AIR 1978 SC 597, the right to life means not only mere survival but also a life with dignity. Hence, Article 21 has since then been expanded to include the right to a clean and healthy environment, right to health and medical care, right to sanitation facilities, right to food and water, etc.
The Supreme Court has addressed a landmark issue with regards to the availability of clean and hygienic washrooms within the High Courts of India in the landmark case of Rajeeb Kalita v. Union of India & Ors. The writ petition was filed by Rajeeb Kalita in 2023 a practicing Advocate enrolled with the Bar Council of Assam. Through this petition, the advocate sought to make separate basic toilet facilities available for men, women, persons with disabilities, and transgender persons.
Relevance was placed upon precedents such as National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (2014) 5 SCC 438 where the topic of separate washrooms for transgenders arose and the SC directed such facilities to be made. International obligations and precedents relied upon include Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 which recognizes the right to a standard of living adequate for health and well-being, including sanitation. Article 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966 underscores the need to improve environmental and industrial hygiene as part of the right to health. The UN General Assembly Resolution No. A/RES/64/292 (2010) acknowledges the right to safe and clean drinking water and sanitation as essential to the full enjoyment of life and human rights.
The Supreme Court expressed its disappointment in the fact that even lady lawyers and lady judicial officers are denied the basic right to a life with dignity. The esteemed Bench has further elucidated: In our opinion, toilets/washrooms/restrooms are not merely a matter of convenience, but a basic necessity which is a facet of human rights. The Constitution declares access to proper sanitation a basic right under Article 21 of the Constitution. Article 21 guarantees the right to life and personal liberty, and it naturally includes a right to a safe and clean environment for everyone. There is a clearly discernible duty on every State/UT under Part IV of the Constitution to ensure a healthy environment and continuously strive for the improvement of public health. Access to justice includes the creation of a pleasant and humane atmosphere for all the stakeholders in the dispensation of justice. The litigants should not be compelled to forego their exercise of legal rights due to fear of sitting in courts for long hours without access to basic amenities. Hence, High Court premises must be equipped with proper washroom facilities for judges, advocates, litigants and staff members, just as required in other public places. Additionally, it is equally essential to ensure that these facilities are adequately provided, maintained and accessible to everyone, sans discomfort or inconvenience.” The Bench has further stressed upon the need for hygiene and sanitation not only in ordinary life but also in court-life.
In light of these considerations, the Supreme Court has given out the following directions:
The High Courts, in conjunction with the respective State Governments/Union Territories (UTs), are directed to ensure the construction and provision of separate toilet facilities for males, females, Persons with Disabilities (PwD), and transgender individuals in all Court premises and Tribunals throughout the Nation. The High Courts shall exercise supervisory jurisdiction to guarantee that such facilities are clearly demarcated and accessible to Judges, advocates, litigants, and court staff.
For effectuating the above, a Committee shall be constituted in each High Court under the chairmanship of a Judge nominated by the Chief Justice, with members comprising the Registrar General/Registrar of the High Court, the Chief Secretary, the Secretary of Public Works Department (PWD), the Finance Secretary of the respective State, a representative of the Bar Association, and any other officer(s) deemed appropriate. The said Committee shall be constituted within six weeks and shall formulate a comprehensive plan to ensure compliance with the following:

1. Statistical Assessment: Ascertain the average daily footfall in the courts and ensure that adequate separate washrooms are constructed and maintained to cater to such numbers.
2. Infrastructure Survey: Conduct a survey to assess the availability, deficiencies in infrastructure, and maintenance gaps concerning toilet facilities.
3. Demarcation and Conversion: Identify existing washrooms and assess the need for converting them to meet the requirements of the specified categories of users.
4. Alternate Facilities: Provide interim arrangements such as mobile toilets during construction, and environment-friendly options like bio-toilets, akin to those utilized by Indian Railways.

5. Special Provisions:
* For women, transgender individuals, and PwD, ensure the provision of clear signage, functional utilities (e.g., water, electricity, flush systems), hand soap, sanitary napkins, toilet paper, and operational plumbing.
* PwD facilities must include ramps and suitably designed washrooms accommodating their needs.

6. Heritage Buildings: For heritage court buildings, maintain architectural integrity by utilizing underutilized spaces, employing modular solutions compatible with existing plumbing, and engaging professionals to modernize sanitation facilities.

7. Cleaning and Maintenance:
*Enforce mandatory cleaning schedules with designated staff, ensuring dry and hygienic conditions.
*Sensitize users regarding clean washroom practices.
*Engage professional agencies on a contract basis to maintain cleanliness and hygiene using modern cleaning techniques and equipment.

8. Inspection and Redressal

Mechanisms:
*Establish a periodic inspection system to ensure the functionality of washrooms, with compliance reports submitted to the designated authority.
*Create a complaint/redressal mechanism for immediate reporting and repair of defective washrooms.

9. Specific Facilities:
*Install working and stocked sanitary pad dispensers in women’s, PwD, and transgender washrooms.
*Ensure child-safe washrooms in Family Court complexes with trained staff for children’s safety and hygiene.
*Provide interconnected rooms adjacent to women’s washrooms with facilities for nursing mothers, including feeding stations and napkin-changing amenities, similar to airport standards.

10. Nodal Officer: Appoint a nodal officer in each court/tribunal premise to oversee maintenance, address complaints, and liaise with the presiding officer or relevant committee. The nodal officer shall ensure complaints are addressed and issue standing instructions in writing concerning the upkeep of washrooms. Responsibilities must be clearly delineated.

11. Fund Allocation and Grading

System:
*Establish a transparent and segregated fund for constructing and maintaining toilet facilities in court complexes.
*Develop a grading system for subordinate courts to ensure sustained quality in maintenance, with certifications and motivation for relevant staff and officials, forming part of their service records.

12. Budgetary Allocations: State Governments/UTs shall allocate adequate funds for constructing, maintaining, and ensuring the cleanliness of toilet facilities in court premises. Such allocations shall be periodically reviewed in consultation with the committee constituted by the High Courts.
All High Courts and the respective State Governments/UTs shall file a status report on compliance with these directions within four months.
The Supreme Court has reaffirmed that the right to life under Article 21 includes dignity and access to basic sanitation. The direction of the Court to High Courts and State Governments/UTs to provide accessible and hygienic toilet facilities in court premises emphasizes the fundamental nature of a clean and accessible environment for all stakeholders. In this regard, the comprehensive guidelines will ensure the construction, maintenance, and inclusion of dedicated funds and oversight mechanisms. These measures reflect the judiciary’s commitment to constitutional values of equality, dignity, and access to justice, demanding strict compliance in order to have a humane and dignified judicial infrastructure.

Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the significance of the Rajeeb Kalita v. Union of India & Ors judgment?

The Supreme Court’s ruling in this case expanded the ambit of Article 21 of the Indian Constitution to include access to hygienic and accessible toilets in High Courts and Tribunals as a fundamental right. It emphasized that proper sanitation is essential to ensuring dignity, a core component of the right to life and personal liberty.

2. Who filed the writ petition in this case, and what were the key issues raised?

The writ petition was filed by Rajeeb Kalita, a practicing advocate enrolled with the Bar Council of Assam. The petition highlighted the lack of proper toilet facilities in court premises, particularly for women, transgender persons, and persons with disabilities, depriving them of their right to dignity under Article 21.

3. What constitutional provisions and precedents were relied upon in the judgment?

The Court relied on Article 21, which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty, and referenced key rulings like:
National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (2014), which recognized the rights of transgender persons, including access to separate washrooms.
The Court also invoked international obligations, such as Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights.

4. What directions did the Supreme Court give in this case?

The Court issued detailed guidelines, including:
*Construction and maintenance of separate toilets for men, women, transgender persons, and PwD in all court premises.
*Formation of a High Court committee to oversee implementation.
*Interim arrangements like mobile toilets and bio-toilets.
*Special provisions for PwD, women, and transgender persons, including ramps, signage, sanitary dispensers, and nursing rooms.
*Regular maintenance, cleaning schedules, and a complaint redressal mechanism.
*Allocation of separate funds for sanitation facilities and periodic inspections to ensure compliance.

5. How does this judgment address the needs of women, transgender persons, and persons with disabilities?

The Court mandated the construction of gender-specific washrooms equipped with features such as ramps, handrails, and child-safe amenities. Special emphasis was placed on providing sanitary napkin dispensers, nursing stations, and clear signage for better accessibility and inclusivity.

6. What interim measures were suggested until permanent facilities are built?

The Court recommended mobile toilets, bio-toilets, and other eco-friendly solutions for immediate use while permanent infrastructure is developed.

7. How does the judgment ensure the maintenance of these facilities?

The Court directed the appointment of nodal officers in each court to oversee maintenance and respond to complaints. It also recommended engaging professional cleaning agencies, creating inspection mechanisms, and introducing a grading system for sustained quality.

8. What funding measures were proposed for implementing these guidelines?

The Court ordered State Governments/UTs to allocate dedicated funds for the construction and maintenance of toilet facilities in court premises. Budget allocations are to be periodically reviewed in consultation with the committee set up by each High Court.

9. Why is this judgment considered a progressive interpretation of Article 21?

By recognizing access to sanitation as a fundamental right, the judgment broadens the scope of Article 21 to include human dignity and equality. It reinforces the connection between basic facilities and access to justice, ensuring a humane environment for all stakeholders.

10. How does the ruling impact court infrastructure and stakeholders?

 The judgment mandates creating an inclusive, accessible, and hygienic judicial infrastructure. This benefits judges, advocates, litigants, and court staff, making courts more welcoming and dignified spaces for everyone, irrespective of gender, ability, or identity.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *