Author : Seema Nazneen
It was during a discussion with my professor about potential research topics that he suggested, “You can research how Muslim women are more prone to vitamin deficiencies (Vitamin D and Vitamin B12) due to wearing hijab.”

This idea resurfaced when I encountered it during academic lectures and research on “Clothing type and Vitamin D status.”

As a medical student and a follower of the Hijab, I was taken aback. But as this idea settled in my mind, an undeniable question arose -Why would Allah, the most Merciful, command something that could harm his creation? Every ruling in the Qur’an aligns with both spiritual well-being and physical health.

Could the Hijab – a symbol of modesty and submission to Allah SWT’s will – truly lead to a deficiency, or is this just another misunderstood correlation?

This piqued my curiosity, so I delved deeper into the research. Let me take you on a journey to uncover the truth behind this claim.

Vitamin D and B12 are crucial nutrients that boost energy, prevent fatigue, improve brain function, maintain strong bones and an immune system, and more. Deficiency of these can lead to fatigue, memory problems, tingling sensations, anaemia, weak bones, joint pains, anxiety, and depression.

But is hijab to blame?

While clothing can limit sun exposure, Vitamin D is not exclusive to hijabis; many people who don’t wear hijab suffer from low Vitamin D levels due to indoor lifestyles, pollution and lack of dietary intake because Vitamin D is not exclusively obtained from sunlight but also from other sources like fatty fish and egg yolks. Indians are also well-known for being Vitamin D deficient overall; this is not limited to a segment of the population, and no direct correlations between levels of clothing and Vitamin D have yet been discovered specifically in the Indian context.

Vitamin B12 is obtained entirely through diet (from meat, fish, egg, and dairy products). However, Vitamin D deficiency can reduce the body’s ability to absorb Vitamin B12. This does not point towards hijab as the cause but instead highlights the importance of a balanced diet (as both vitamins are majorly obtained from the diet), meaning their deficiency is more about what we eat than what we wear!

When specifically interrogating this commonly held belief about Muslim women, we can also trace it back to colonial and Orientalist literature, which connected the idea of pardah to disease, which scholars like Ilyse R. Morgenstein Fuerst have traced in their academic studies. After all this analysis and reflection, I arrived at a clear conclusion – Hijab is not the cause of Vitamin deficiencies. Blaming the Hijab for nutritional deficiencies oversimplifies a complex health issue. However, when I step into the real world, I see many cases in the OPD of Muslim girls and women complaining of Vitamin deficiencies. However, these are anecdotal experiences, and my interactions with a few patients cannot be a representative sample to prove a correlation. It sparks a deeper question: Why are these deficiencies so prevalent if the Hijab isn’t the cause?

Then I suddenly realised we often neglect our diet, but Islam strongly emphasises moderation and a balanced diet.

The Qur’an also highlights the importance of consuming Tayyib (pure and wholesome food).

“Eat of the good things which we have provided for you.”(Qur’an 2:172)

There is also a Hadith from Tirmidhi (Hadith 2304) where Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:

“Take advantage of five before five: Your Youth before your old age; Your Health before your Illness; Your wealth before your Poverty; Your free time before your busyness, and Your life before your Death.”

To take advantage of your Health, you need to practice habits that will prevent you from developing these deficiencies.

  • Get enough sunlight exposure (15 minutes a day)
  • Take foods rich in Vitamins (meat, fish, dairy products, green leafy vegetables)
  • Take supplements if needed (consult your doctor before you do so)
  • Do proper physical exercise

    After this contemplation, I now firmly believe, more than before, that Allah does not command anything that could harm His creation. Linking hijab to vitamin deficiencies is a misconception; our health depends on a balanced diet and lifestyle, not attire. As health is a trust in Allah, we must nurture it to strengthen our ability to worship, work, and serve others. Islam values strength, and taking care of our body is not just self-care but an act of worship.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *