The author is a renowned journalist.

Chief Minister Approaches the Supreme Court
In an unprecedented and extremely significant move concerning the conduct of free and fair elections in the country, the West Bengal Chief Minister and President of the All India Trinamool Congress, Mamata Banerjee, on Wednesday, 4th February 2026, appeared before the Supreme Court Bench headed by the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, challenging the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the electoral rolls in the state.
After hearing the Chief Minister, as well as advocates representing the State, the Election Commission of India (ECI), and other parties, the Bench — also comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V.M. Pancholi — issued notice to the Election Commission and the Union Government. The Chief Justice further directed the ECI to instruct its officers to be more “sensitive” while issuing show-cause notices to voters.
Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee submitted that the SIR exercise was being undertaken primarily for the deletion of voters’ names rather than their inclusion. She pointed out that women who change surnames after marriage or shift residences were being deleted from the rolls on grounds of “mismatch”.
She further contended that Aadhaar was not being accepted as a valid document by the ECI, which, she argued, constituted a violation of the directions issued by the Supreme Court on 8 September 2025 in the challenge to the Bihar SIR.
Mamata Banerjee also stated that the Election Commission had neither replied to nor acknowledged the six letters she had sent. She argued that the exercise was being selectively carried out in West Bengal on the eve of the state elections. Additionally, she questioned the pace of the revision process, observing: “They want to do something in two months which is normally done in two years.”
Concerns Over Deletions and Procedural Irregularities
Mamata Banerjee further pointed out that micro-observers had been appointed from BJP-ruled states, allegedly “superseding” the powers of Electoral Registration Officers (EROs) and Booth Level Officers (BLOs). She claimed that, during the first phase of the SIR, the names of 58 lakh voters had been arbitrarily deleted and that hundreds of living individuals had been declared dead.
She also alleged that the ECI was issuing instructions informally, effectively converting itself into a “WhatsApp Commission”. In response, the Chief Justice observed that the Court would direct the Commission to ensure that all decisions and documents be authorised by the BLOs.
Advocate for the State of West Bengal, Shyam Divan, submitted that despite the Court’s earlier order mandating transparency and adequate opportunity for voters placed in the Logical Discrepancy (LD) category, the ECI had failed to comply. Although the Court had granted an additional ten days, only four days now remained before the deadline.
Divan further noted that 1.36 crore voters had been placed in the LD list, while 32 lakh voters had been categorised as “unmapped”. Hearings, he argued, were yet to be completed in respect of 62 lakh voters, making it impossible to finalise the process of revision and inclusion within the stipulated timeframe.
He also submitted that, although the Supreme Court had directed disclosure of reasons for inclusion in the LD list, the Commission had uploaded only names, age, and gender. The “reasons” column, he pointed out, merely contained cryptic codes.
Spelling Variations and the Debate on ‘Logical Discrepancy’
A substantial number of LD cases, Divan argued, arose from minor spelling variations when Bengali names were translated into English. He cited examples such as Dutta/Datta, Roy/Ray, and variations in parents’ names due to middle names or transliteration inconsistencies. He submitted that more than 70 lakh LD cases were attributable to such minor mismatches and therefore urged the ECI to withdraw these notices, describing them as unavoidable harassment of citizens.
This raises an important question: who within the ECI coined the term “Logical Discrepancy”? Common sense would suggest that a discrepancy, by definition, cannot be logical. It is unlikely that the Chief Election Commissioner or the Election Commissioners — all highly educated individuals — would have introduced such terminology. Whoever coined the term, the author remarks, deserves recognition.
Chief Justice Surya Kant observed that withdrawing notices issued under the LD category might not be practical. However, he acknowledged that dialectal and spelling variations occur across the country and that bona fide individuals cannot be excluded from electoral rolls due to such errors.
On the question of the admissibility of Aadhaar as a document for voter registration, the Chief Justice observed that the Court could not comment on its evidentiary value, as judgment on the legality of the SIR process itself had been reserved.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta submitted that an atmosphere of hostility towards election officials prevailed in West Bengal. He further argued that a pending Public Interest Litigation (PIL) seeking protection for ECI officials should be heard alongside the present petition.



0 Comments