The author is a renowned journalist
Subverting the Constitution through the President’s Letter
Joseph Maliakan
Supreme Court Rebukes Governors and Sets Clear Timelines
Just a month after the Supreme Court, on a petition by the Tamil Nadu Government, set a deadline for the President and the State Governors to give assent to bills passed by the legislature, in an unprecedented and perhaps unconstitutional move, President Droupadi Murmu has written to the Supreme Court questioning whether timelines could be imposed on the President and Governors by the Constitutional Courts.
In April, a Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice R. Mahadevan, using the Supreme Court’s Special Powers to resolve the face-off between the DMK government in Tamil Nadu and Governor R.N. Ravi, ruled that the Governor’s refusal to approve 10 bills passed by the State Legislature was “ILLEGAL AND ARBITRARY.”
Significantly, the Supreme Court, in its order, set a THREE-MONTH deadline for the President and Governors to clear bills passed by the legislature a second time. The judgment also said the President MUST consult the Courts on constitutional matters. The Bench, however, clarified that if the matter pertains to policies, the Supreme Court can refuse to express its advisory opinion.
Limits on Executive Authority in Constitutional Matters
“However, in certain exceptional circumstances, the Governor may reserve a Bill for consideration of the President on the grounds that the bill is perilous to the principles of democracy and an interpretation of the Constitution is necessary to ascertain whether such legislation should be granted assent or not. In such cases where a bill has been reserved majorly on the ground of not being in consonance with constitutional principles and involves questions of constitutional validity, the executive is supposed to exercise restraint,” the order said.
“It is expected that the Union Executive SHOULD NOT ASSUME THE ROLE OF THE COURTS in determining the VIRES of the bill, and should, as a matter of practice, refer such questions to the Supreme Court under Article 143.
“We have no qualms in stating that the hands of the Executive are tied when engaging with purely legal issues in a bill and only the Constitutional Courts have the prerogative to study and provide recommendations as regards the constitutionality of a bill,” the order said.
The order clarified that the Court is aware of the “non-binding nature” of its advisory jurisdiction. “However, merely because the jurisdiction under Article 143 is not binding does not undermine the principles used by this Court to determine the constitutionality of the bill,” the judgment said.
President’s Letter Seen as Review Petition in Disguise
The order clarified that the only reason for which the legislature or the executive wing may not take note of the Supreme Court’s opinion, “is when the grounds on which a State bill was reserved for the consideration of the President, are not purely legal but also involve certain policy considerations which may outweigh the issue of constitutionality.”
“In such cases, if the President acts contrary to the advice of this Court and withholds assent to a bill, she must record cogent reasons and materials that justify not granting assent,” the order stressed.
Under Article 143 (Power of the President to consult the Supreme Court), if at any time it appears to the President that a question of law or fact has arisen, or is likely to arise, which is of such a nature and of such public importance that it is expedient to obtain the opinion of the Supreme Court upon it, she may refer the question to the Court for consideration and the Court may, after such hearing as it thinks fit, report to the President its opinion thereon.
There have been 14 Presidential references so far under Article 143. The present reference differs from the previous references in that it reads like a review petition against the Supreme Court judgment of April 8, 2025, in the case filed by the Tamil Nadu Government against Governor R.N. Ravi for withholding assent to 10 bills passed by the Tamil Nadu legislature.
Political Ramifications and Legal Misinterpretations
President Murmu, in her letter, asked whether timelines could be imposed on Governors. The question is very irrelevant because the Supreme Court in its order on 8 April fixed a time limit of three months for giving assent to bills not only to the Governors but also to the President!
The President further asks, “Is the Governor bound by the aid and advice tendered by the Council of Ministers while exercising all the options available with her when a bill is presented under Article 200 of the Constitution of India?” Any undergraduate law student will tell you that under the Constitution, the Governors are bound by the advice of the Council of Ministers in all matters of governance. It is a different matter that lately some Governors have been behaving as though they are representatives of the British Raj.
The President also asked if the Governor’s exercise of constitutional discretion is justiciable. There have been innumerable cases both in the High Courts and Supreme Court in which the Governors’ decisions have been found to be unconstitutional. Only two years ago, the Kerala High Court set aside the decision of the Kerala Governor to sack the Vice-Chancellors of some State Universities.
Referring to the President’s letter, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin said that this is the Union Government’s attempt to “subvert constitutional position already settled” by the Supreme Court in the Tamil Nadu case. “This attempt clearly exposes the fact that the Tamil Nadu Governor acted at the BJP’s behest to undermine the people’s mandate. This is nothing but a desperate attempt to weaken democratically elected State Governments by placing them under the control of Governors serving as agents of the Union Government.
It also directly challenges the majesty of law and the authority of the Supreme Court as the final interpreter of the Constitution,” Stalin added.
Stop Persecution in the name of Religious Conversion: Supreme Court warns U.P. Police
Supreme Court Quashes FIRs Against SHUATS Vice Chancellor
The Supreme Court on 23 May 2025 set aside two First Information Reports (FIRs) registered against Vinod Bihari Lal, the Vice Chancellor of Prayagraj-based Sam Higginbottom University of Agriculture, Technology and Sciences (SHUATS), alleging illegal religious conversions.
In the FIRs registered in July 2018, the U.P. Police alleged that Lal and one David Dutta formed a gang for committing economic offences involving fraud and cheating for personal and material gain by forging documents. The police also alleged that Lal misused Rs. 34.5 crore received from foreign sources to find illegal religious conversions. The FIRs were registered under the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act 1986 and the Uttar Pradesh Prohibition of Unlawful Conversion of Religion Act 2020.
The police investigated and submitted a charge sheet under which a trial court issued non-bailable arrest warrants against the two in February 2023.
Judges Criticise Mechanical and Unlawful Police Procedure
The Supreme Court bench, which was comprised of Justice JB Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, said in their order that the charge sheet prepared against Lal and another accused was a mere reproduction of the FIR. The rules were thrown out of the window as a mechanically drawn pre-prepared gang chart was “rubber stamped” by the competent authority without following the mandate under the Gangster Act that laid down a process of consultation followed by satisfaction of senior police officials and district authorities.
Finding that nothing of this was done before registering the FIR against Lal in 2018, the SC bench pointed out: “Resultantly, the registration of the subject FIR is in complete violation of the procedural safeguards. We are at pains to observe that authorities entrusted with the solemn duty of safeguarding life and liberty treat it with such casual indifference, truly a case of the fox guarding the henhouse.”
Lack of Evidence and Abuse of Power
The bench further said that a perusal of the case files reveals that the police did not investigate, and the chargesheet, a reproduction of the FIR, concluded that the accused were guilty without furnishing any documentary evidence.
“The contents of the chargesheet reflect a casual and cavalier attitude on the part of the investigating agency, as it discloses nothing beyond what was already stated in the subject FIR. The order said that we strongly disapprove of this practice and cast into the cold storage wherein the investigating authority proclaims an offence to be ‘proved’.
The judgement authored by Justice Pardiwala further said that a mechanical or routine exercise of power by the recommending, forwarding and approving authorities, respectively, is impermissible, as it directly impinges upon the liberty of citizens …we would like to reiterate that the recommending, forwarding, and approving authority are not mere rubber-stamping entities.
The order reminded the investigating agency of its job to conduct an impartial investigation and leave it to the trial court to determine the guilt or innocence of the accused.
Anti-Conversion Law as a Tool of Harassment
Senior advocate Sidharth Dave, who appeared for Lal, pointed out that the FIR under the Gangster Act was based on three base FIRs registered in 2017, and while a gang requires more than one person, the co-accused Dutta is not named in any FIR.
In this context, the Supreme Court order said, “This selective approach raises serious doubts about the bonafide of the investigating agency and integrity of the investigation undertaken under the Act of 1986.” Dave also questioned the “mechanical preparation of the gang chart, highlighting how, at every stage, the U.P. Gangster Rules 2021 stood violated.
The bench further said that: “Upon perusal of the material on record, more particularly the gang-chart, it is abundantly clear that the said gang -chart was approved by the competent authority merely by affixing his / her signature on a pre-printed gang-chart, an act that reflects nothing short of a complete non–application of mind and constitutes a violation of Rule 16 and 17 of 2021 Rules … Such a safeguard is integral to preserving the procedural sanctity of law and preventing arbitrary or perfunctory approvals that may adversely affect the rights and liberties of individuals.”
The police investigation only ignites “conjectures and surmises” without making out a prima facie case, so the Bench concluded that “continuation of criminal proceedings against the appellant herein would result in undue harassment when there is no material against him and will result in the abuse of the process of law.”
The Supreme Court had earlier, on 16 May 2025, stayed criminal proceedings before the trial court in Uttar Pradesh over five cases lodged against the Vice-Chancellor of the Sam Higginbottom University and others for alleged illegal conversion of Hindus to Christianity.
Senior lawyer Mukta Gupta, appearing for one of the accused, had pointed out that the testimony of none of the alleged victims of conversion, who were lured into Christianity, was recorded by the state police.
In the last four years, 835 cases have been registered, and 1,682 people have been arrested under the Uttar Pradesh Prohibition of Unlawful Conversion of Religion Act 2020. So far, 124 people named in complaints have been let off after their involvement could not be proved. According to social observers, the law has only resulted in the harassment of ordinary people.



0 Comments