Category : Explainer Series

The author holds a postgraduate degree in Political Science and is a research associate and freelance writer.

“On the 26th of January 1950, we will enter into a life of contradictions. In politics we will have equality and in social and economic life we will have inequality. In politics, we will be recognising the principle of one man one vote and one vote one value. In our social and economic life, we shall, because of our social and economic structure, continue to deny the principle of one man one value.

How long shall we continue to live this life of contradictions?

How long shall we continue to deny equality in our social and economic life?

If we continue to deny it for long, we will do so only by putting our political democracy in peril. We must remove this contradiction at the earliest possible moment, or else those who suffer from inequality will blow up the structure of political democracy which this Assembly has so laboriously built up.”

― Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar, Writings And Speeches: A Ready Reference Manual

Introduction

Justice, often understood as an abstract ideal, virtue, or ethic, is a problem of moral philosophy. However, to achieve its aims, a political order must implement it, making it a matter of political philosophy.

It is a concept with various dimensions, such as legal justice (rule of law), political justice (justice and fairness in matters of political rights, political process, etc), or socio-economic justice (the combination of the ideas of social justice and economic justice).

In particular, social justice is an aspect that concerns itself with the idea of social change. The political philosopher, D.D. Raphael said, “The term ‘social justice’ tends to issue from the mouths of reformers and to be regarded with suspicion by those who are satisfied with the existing order.” Much of Dr Ambedkar’s life and work revolved around similar sentiments, including his final words to the Constituent Assembly in Independent India.

Martha Nussbaum wrote about how a just society fosters the capabilities of individuals to engage in activities that are essential to a truly “human” life—including, among others, the capabilities to live a life of normal length, to use one’s mind in ways “protected by guarantees of freedom of expression,”

The Indian Context

In a society like India, where the most predominant force that shapes social structures is caste, the idea of social justice is inconceivable without social change.

In Annihilation of Caste, Dr Ambedkar explains how caste structures Indian society, its brutal reality, analysing how it affects not just those whom it oppresses (i.e. Dalit-Bahujan people) but even those who purportedly benefit from it (i.e. dominant-caste people). He offers solutions for the same, the gist of which is suggested by the title of the book itself, in other words, no meaningful sense of justice can be achieved unless caste is completely done away with.

Caste is a form of graded inequality where social groups, called castes, are arranged in a rigid hierarchy (“a tower with no staircase”). At the top are the Brahmins, followed by Kshatriyas, Vaishyas, and Shudras, with Dalits (then referred to as “Untouchables”) being outside this system and treated as sub-human. Endogamy, or the practice of marrying within one’s caste, is one of the defining features of the caste system. This practice has historically ensured that caste distinctions remain rigid and immutable. Caste is ascribed at birth and determines an individual’s social status, occupation, and access to resources, with no possibility of mobility. This creates rigid boundaries between communities, preventing intermixing and fostering exclusion, prejudice, and hostility.

The strict confinement of individuals to hereditary occupations results in what Dr Ambedkar described as a “division of labourers,” not a division of labour (as was and is being justified or whitewashed). People deemed to be of “lower castes”, particularly Dalits, are denied basic human rights, education, and access to public spaces.

Today, thousands of caste groups exist in India, and many more sub-castes exist within a broader caste group. The Brahmins, who sit at the top of the caste hierarchy, encompass subgroups like the Saraswat Brahmins in Goa, Maharashtra, and Karnataka; the Iyers, a Tamil Brahmin community in Tamil Nadu; and the Gaur Brahmins in North India.

The Kshatriyas include the Rajputs of Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, and Gujarat, the Marathas of Maharashtra, and the Khatris in Punjab and Himachal Pradesh.

The Vaishyas, traditionally engaged in commerce and trade, feature communities like the Agrawals in North India, the Jains, who are found across India with a significant presence in Rajasthan and Gujarat, and the Komatis of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana.

The Shudras, historically associated with service and labour roles, include groups like the Yadavs of North India, the Kurubas of Karnataka, and the Ezhavas of Kerala.

Beyond these, the Dalits, often referred to as Scheduled Castes and historically marginalised, consist of subgroups such as the Jatavs in Uttar Pradesh, the Madigas in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, and the Paraiyars in Tamil Nadu.

Subcastes include the Vokkaligas, an agrarian community in Karnataka, which is divided into subgroups such as the Gangadikara and Morasu. Similarly, the Reddys, a landowning class in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, include subcategories like the Kapu Reddys and Panta Reddys.

Among the Scheduled Tribes (STs), major communities include the Santhalo live in Jharkhand, Bihar, Odisha, and West Bengal, and the Gonds, who reside primarily in Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, and Chhattisgarh.

The intersection of caste and class

In India, especially after the neoliberal economic reforms in the 90s, the socio-economic categorisation of class became more significant than ever before. Class, unlike caste, is not fixed or localised. Since it is based on economic factors like income and wealth and largely uninfluenced by religion or culture, there is the possibility of both ‘upward mobility’ (eg. a person can go from being working class to middle class) as well as impoverishment (eg. from being middle-class, a person could return to working class/low-income status due to financial hardships).

However, in India, the class has coexisted with caste and power. In India today, there are four main classes: (i) agrarian classes, (ii) industrial classes, (iii) business and trade classes, and (iv) professional classes. You’ll find that these socio-economic class categories often overlap with caste-based occupations, although not always. In any case, they are intertwined and not immune from the socio-cultural baggage of caste, which makes the argument for pure economic-based reservation redundant.

Many people today think that because reservation exists and a certain amount of improvement in the socio-economic status of certain sections of the Dalit-Bahujan populace (i.e. “creamy layer”) can be observed, this is proof that equal opportunity exists. Therefore, reservations should only be made on an economic basis. This is why it’s important to understand that the provision of reservation (also known as affirmative action) is not a poverty alleviation welfare scheme; rather, it is meant to ensure the representation of all sections of society in an institution, organisation, etc. The economic benefits of the reservation are availed by only a limited number of people belonging to Dalit-Bahujan-Adivasi communities, and even then, it does not protect them from social discrimination.

Despite the Constitution abolishing untouchability (the evil practice of social exclusion practised by upper-caste communities that target people from lower-caste) and providing for important reforms and safeguards such as reservation, caste continued to be a defining feature. Why?

This is due to several reasons. The caste system has been ingrained in Indian society for centuries, shaping people’s identities, occupations, and social interactions. Social conditioning has normalised caste hierarchies, and these perceptions persist despite constitutional interventions. Practices like endogamy (marriage within one’s caste) continue to reinforce caste boundaries, maintaining rigid social divisions.

Historically, lower castes were denied land, education, and wealth-generating opportunities. This economic deprivation has perpetuated a cycle of poverty.

Many Dalits and marginalised castes continue to work in low-paying, stigmatised occupations, while higher castes dominate industries, professions, and political power structures.

While reservations have improved access to education and jobs for marginalised communities, implementation has been inconsistent.

Corruption and bureaucratic inefficiencies often dilute the impact of policies designed to uplift lower castes.

Many marginalised groups still face barriers to accessing justice, education, and healthcare, perpetuating inequality.

Caste-based discrimination remains pervasive, especially in rural areas where traditional hierarchies are more rigidly enforced.

Practices like untouchability, though outlawed, continue to occur covertly or overtly in various forms, such as restrictions on water sources, temple entry, or housing segregation.

Most importantly, it is because the caste system is so deeply tied to religious practices and beliefs. Ritual purity and pollution concepts persist in societal norms and customs. Resistance to change is often rooted in cultural and religious ideologies that uphold caste distinctions as sacred or immutable.

Another major concern in the struggle for social justice is gender justice. India, deemed one of the most dangerous countries in the world for women, continues to lag on indicators of gender justice. Again, gender, in the Indian context, cannot be discussed without referencing how caste influences it. Gender and caste intersect to create layered systems of oppression, particularly for women from marginalised castes. While caste determines social status and access to resources, gender compounds the discrimination faced by women within these hierarchies. Upper-caste women often navigate restrictions tied to patriarchal notions of purity and honour, while lower-caste women endure both caste-based violence and gender-based exploitation. Dalit and Adivasi women, for instance, are disproportionately affected by sexual violence, labour exploitation, and limited access to education and healthcare. These intersecting inequalities highlight the need for policies and movements that address the simultaneous impacts of caste and gender discrimination to achieve true social equality.

Women in India have played a pivotal role in shaping the social justice discourse and leading transformative movements across history. In the context of caste, figures like Savitribai Phule, often hailed as India’s first feminist, championed education for girls and Dalit children alongside her husband, Jyotirao Phule. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s wife, Ramabai Ambedkar, supported Dalit empowerment and worked closely with women to address issues of untouchability.

In the independence movement, women like Sarojini Naidu and Kasturba Gandhi fought for political rights while addressing social issues such as untouchability and gender inequality. In post-independence India, women leaders like Ela Bhatt founded organisations like SEWA (Self-Employed Women’s Association) to empower women workers in informal sectors. Activists like Medha Patkar spearheaded the Narmada Bachao Andolan, emphasising the intersection of environmental justice and the displacement of marginalised communities.

Feminist groups such as the All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA) and Dalit Women’s Fight have actively challenged patriarchal and casteist structures. Women-led movements against caste-based violence, such as the campaign following the Hathras rape case, highlight the enduring fight for dignity and justice. These contributions underscore women’s crucial role in advocating for equitable and inclusive social justice in India.

Given the deeply entrenched religious sanction behind the caste system, it’s clear that the long-term project of its elimination will require more than solely politico-socio-economic reforms in society. Realising this goal will prove extremely difficult without a moral and spiritual transformation.

Islamic teachings and ritual practices, such as collective prayer in mosques, sharing meals, particularly when breaking fasts during the month of Ramadan, the emphasis on paying wealth tax and donating to charity (in other words, the circulation of wealth in society), and the repeated emphasis on righteousness through one’s actions rather than one’s lineage, place of birth, or origin, all inculcate a sense of innate egalitarianism and brotherhood.

There are multiple instances in India’s history of entire villages converting to Islam, reassured by the dignity and equality of the faith. In his poignant and moving essay, “Why I converted to Islam and buried my Hindu identity”, Dalit Camera founder Raees Mohammed writes, “In my years of research, I too found Islam to be the only religion in India with the strength to annihilate the caste system.”

References:
An Introduction to Political Theory, O.P. Gauba
Social justice | Definition, Theories, Examples, & Facts | Britannica
Intersection of Class & Caste, JMI, Sociology

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *