Category : Explainer Series
The author is a published writer and artist and holds an MA in Comparative
Literatures and Culture

The Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement in opposition to the Israeli genocide has been eye-opening in many ways. On the one hand, the dropping profits of boycotted brands and their increased advertising efforts have shown us how much power rests in our hands. On the other, unfortunately, it has brought to light how often we put luxuries over the well-being and safety of our fellow man. While people worldwide are sharing videos and posts about the genocide in Palestine, they are undermined by the same person posting cutesy selfies holding a Starbucks cup or a McDonalds burger. The disappointing truth is that far too many people support justice and will say so until it is a slight inconvenience. The question that keeps coming up is this: “Why is it my responsibility?”
Why is it your responsibility to care about the injustices in the world? Why does it fall to you to stop purchasing from corporations who are complicit in these injustices rather than to the corporations themselves? The easy answer is that corporations will only change once they have reason to, and the only reason they would have is if their practices are making them lose money. Your money, when you refuse to give it to them.
The real answer, however, is more complicated. We are hurtling towards an individualistic culture that normalises putting one’s comforts and luxuries over the collective good. This trend towards individualism is beneficial only to the ones in power. The greatest threat to any oppressive system, capitalism included, is the people it oppresses. It is not just helpful but essential to the powers that be that the people remain divided; as long as people only care for themselves and perhaps the people in their immediate social circle, they will not unite, they will not organise, and they will accept the power structures as they presented. Strength lies in numbers, and so does survival. Capitalism benefits from alienating people from their communities.
A practical example is the shift towards nuclear families in a society steadily moving towards individualism over collectivism. This shift means that any task that cannot be accomplished by two adults with certain schedules in mind becomes a commodity: cooking, childcare, cleaning, emotional support, helping children with homework, etc. Between HelloFresh style meal plan companies getting popularised worldwide and nannying and cleaning services, we exchange money for the community experience without the community. David Brooks’s article in The Atlantic, The Nuclear Family Was a Mistake, said: “The shift from bigger and interconnected extended families to smaller and detached nuclear families ultimately led to a familial system that liberates the rich and ravages the working-class and the poor.”
The survival of human beings over millennia has been contingent on community living and caring for one another. There is a reason every religion in the world preaches a need for the same. “Love thy neighbour as thyself” is considered the Golden Rule in the Bible.

Surah An-Nisa, in the Quran, says “O believers! Stand firm for justice as witnesses for Allah, even if it is against yourselves, your parents, or close relatives. Be they rich or poor, Allah is best to ensure their interests. So do not let your desires cause you to deviate from justice.” (Qur’an – 4:135)

Today, humanity is standing witness as our fellow man gets ravaged. Palestine, Sudan, Congo; thanks to modern technology, we are watching the war unfold, and lives get destroyed. It is no longer a distant reality, relegated to the back of your mind with everything you know is true but haven’t seen first-hand. Historically, emotional or physical proximity has been a huge factor in sympathising with the oppressed. Technology has bridged physical proximity; however, emotional proximity seems to have stretched further. People are voting fascists into power when the people who the regime will hurt are their neighbours and coworkers. People are giving up lifelong friendships for the sake of hateful ideologies. Pastor Martin Niemöller’s First They Came For is an oft-quoted poem, and for good reason. The poem begins with “First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out because I was not a Communist,” runs through every community that came under fire before them, ending with, “Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak out for me.” Simple and poignant.
The BDS movement is a global mobilisation movement, giving the power of change to people, regardless of wealth. It gives you, at home, the power to contribute something towards justice. The simple act of boycotting certain brands gives them the message that the consumer will not stand for them, contributing to genocide. Since they prioritise profit over everything, it will incite change if something makes them lose a large chunk of their consumer base. This isn’t theoretical; we are watching the results of these efforts in real-time. The Strauss Group has had to sell Sabra due to declining sales. Puma has stopped sponsoring the Israeli Football Association. AXA sold its shares in all major Israeli banks under pressure from protestors.

What is conscious consumerism? It is simply being aware of whose hands your money goes into as often as possible. It makes purchasing decisions considering social, political, and ethical concerns. It involves avoiding brands not aligning with one’s values and seeking out ones that do. BDS is just one example of it, a vital one that has gained global traction, but just one example all the same. Considering how often corporations are caught doing blatantly unethical things, this may seem a huge task at first glance. After all, there is no ethical consumption under capitalism. Within a system that prioritises profits over anything, it becomes inevitable that any purchase has collateral damage. Be it the environmental repercussions of same-day delivery, worker exploitation in sweatshops, or ethically questionable acquisition of resources, there is often something sinister going on in the background that the consumer knows nothing about. Owing to this, it becomes almost impossible to make purchases without stepping on someone’s back. “There is no ethical consumption under capitalism” was a phrase coined to take undue blame away from the consumer and put it at the feet of the corporations who, in the name of profit, excuse man’s suffering. However, it has, today, been co-opted to shirk responsibility when knowingly making purchases from brands with dubious ethics. The point is that “There is no ethical consumption under capitalism” must not be followed by, “Therefore, I am not responsible for the harm caused by my purchases.” It must be followed: “But I will do my best to minimise harm.”
Conscious consumerism looks different for consumers. It will look different depending on where you live, your wealth, and what causes you to align with the most. Environmental activists may boycott Amazon, considering Amazon released 71 metric tons of carbon emissions in 2021. Animal rights activists may boycott L’Oreal, who, according to PETA, still does animal testing. Human rights activists may boycott Nestle, who have been accused of a laundry list of human rights violations, from using child labour to groundwater contamination. One’s moral values cannot only be the words one speaks or writes; they must extend to our daily practices. It doesn’t have to be complicated. Start small: simply reduce your consumption. Stop unnecessary overconsumption, and be mindful of what you buy. If possible, borrow, upcycle or reuse to reduce your consumption. Shop locally as often as you can to avoid large corporations. Not only is this environmentally conscious, but it also helps support local businesses in staying afloat. Trade clothes and jewellery among friends and family. Buy things second-hand. Small steps to make it easier to be a conscious consumer. Capitalism permeates everything in our lives. When something is overwhelmingly present in our lives, its power seems impossible. It is easy to fall prey to hopelessness and the assumption that change is impossible. However, it is essential to remember that fatalism plays into their narrative that the world is flawed beyond change and a lost cause. A lost cause means you don’t have to fight for it. A lost cause means you get to give up, sit back, and watch the world burn. The people in power desperately want you to believe it’s a lost cause because hope fuels every revolution.
Why is it your responsibility? Because in this world, we are each other’s caretakers. Our alliances must be with the oppressed and not the oppressor. Why is it your responsibility? You want to create because you are responsible for participating in the work. A better future doesn’t simply come into being; it is the product of effort. If the Palestinian cause is something you believe in, then you must decide that no amount of convenience or luxury is worth allowing your money to support the massacre. Why is it your responsibility? Because it is your money and not a penny should be drenched in blood.
I will leave you with a pertinent quote by Hugo and Nebula award-winning writer Ursula K. Le Guin: “We live in capitalism, its power seems inescapable — but then, so did the divine right of kings. Any human power can be resisted and changed by human beings.”

1 Comment

  1. Jameel Ahmed

    Very meaningful column that is need of the hour , explaining BDS it’s impacts and realization of power we do have in unity . Each individual need to realize our responsibility carefully.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *