Category : LEGAL DESK

The author is a renowned journalist

A Sudden and Controversial Move

The haste with which the Election Commission of India (ECI) on Monday, October 27, announced a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voters’ lists in 12 States and Union Territories has aroused serious suspicion about the real intention behind the move.

Is the Commission, on the pretext of revising the voters’ list, attempting to make a National Register of Citizens? Or is it trying to remove marginalised sections of the population from the electoral roll — like minorities, especially Muslims, Dalits, and backward classes — who are known for opposing the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) led by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)?

The ECI announced a nationwide SIR through a circular issued on 24 June 2025. The first phase of SIR, the circular said, would be held in Bihar ahead of the Assembly election scheduled for November 2025.

Soon, a number of writ petitions were filed in the Supreme Court by individuals and political parties challenging the SIR as being unconstitutional because it violated provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1950.

The petitioners argued that the Bihar SIR is illegal because it ignored the electoral roll revisions undertaken by the ECI up to January 2025 and went back to the 2003 electoral roll as the basis for revision. In the SIR, the Commission asked all those voters who were not listed in the 2003 electoral roll to apply afresh with one or more of 11 documents identified by the ECI as proof of citizenship.

The ECI excluded the voter ID issued by the Commission and the Aadhaar card as proof of citizenship for inclusion in the voters’ list. On the intervention of the Supreme Court, the Commission reluctantly agreed to accept the Aadhaar card for inclusion in the list.

Violating Law and Overstepping Authority

The Representation of the People Act, 1950, states that inclusion in the voters’ list will be done on a self-declaration of citizenship backed by one of six documents listed in Form 6 of the 1950 Rules: birth certificate, matriculation certificate, passport, Aadhaar card, PAN card, and driving licence.

The 11 documents now being demanded by the Commission to prove one’s citizenship ironically exclude the Aadhaar card, PAN card, and driving licence. The Commission has arbitrarily changed the Rules of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 — something only Parliament is empowered to do. Do the Election Commissioners think they are above the law?

Further, the Supreme Court in its 1995 judgment in the Lal Babu Hussein case held that once a person has been registered in the voters’ list, the voter’s name cannot be removed except by holding an inquiry into the citizenship of the voter and after giving an opportunity to be heard. Therefore, the SIR is being carried out in clear violation of the Supreme Court order, for it ignores the Commission’s own revisions since 2003.

In other words, the Commission is not only looking at all voters with suspicion but also questioning the authenticity of its own work.

The 27 October announcement by the Commission for SIR has come even as the Supreme Court is hearing the challenge to its actions. The second phase of the SIR is to be held in 12 States and Union Territories including West Bengal and Tamil Nadu (both of which will hold elections in 2026) and Uttar Pradesh, which will vote in 2027.

The electoral rolls in Andaman and Nicobar, Chhattisgarh, Goa, Gujarat, Kerala, Lakshadweep, Madhya Pradesh, Puducherry, and Rajasthan will also be revised in this phase. Since citizenship rules in Assam differ from the rest of the country, the voters’ list revision in that State will be held later.

In the second phase, enumeration will take place from 4 November to 4 December. Draft rolls will be released on 9 December. Voters removed from the rolls can appeal up to 8 January 2026. The final revised rolls will be published by 7 February 2026.

The SIR, on close examination, is not just a revision of the voters’ list. It is being carried out in clear violation of the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, and its Rules. By demanding fresh documents to prove citizenship, the ECI has usurped the powers of the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. By changing the rules for inclusion in the electoral roll, the Commission has also encroached upon the powers of Parliament, which alone has legislative authority.

From Trust to Suspicion

Between 1947 and 1950, when India did not yet have any citizenship laws, the country prepared its first electoral roll. It was made on the basis of trust in the people of the country. But today, things have turned upside down — the ECI is approaching people with suspicion.

The onus of proving citizenship has been transferred to the individual, most of whom do not possess the documents demanded by the Commission. Ordinary citizens in the country often have only a ration card or Aadhaar card, which the Commission refuses to accept as proof of citizenship.

The first voters’ list was based on natural membership or default belonging, not on proven citizenship, because the majority of Indians then, and even now, do not possess any proof of citizenship. The basic approach towards the people is no longer based on trust but on suspicion.

The burden of proof of citizenship now lies on the individual, not on the powerful state or its agencies. The mandate of the Commission is to conduct free and fair elections, not to determine anyone’s citizenship. It is a blatant violation of the Constitution by the ECI. The umpire has become the gatekeeper.

The SIR, on close examination, is not just a revision of the voters’ list. It is being carried out in clear violation of the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, and its Rules. By demanding fresh documents to prove citizenship, the ECI has usurped the powers of the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. By changing the rules for inclusion in the electoral roll, the Commission has also encroached upon the powers of Parliament, which alone has legislative authority.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *