The author is a 2nd year biotechnology undergraduate from Ranchi, Jharkhand, with a passion for exploring science and expressing ideas through stories, poems, and personal experiences.

That day, I was chatting with a friend when she casually said,
“Muslims are very kattar (extreme).”
I raised an eyebrow. “Kattar in what way?”
She replied, “Like… if someone doesn’t follow Islam properly, or if a woman doesn’t wear a hijab, or if someone says something about Islam — Muslims kill them.”
I paused. Not in shock — I’ve heard versions of this before — but in disappointment at how easily these narratives spread, and how rarely they are questioned.
So I asked her, “Where do you think this image of Muslims comes from? Is it based on real people you’ve known, or what you’ve seen online, in films, news cycles?”
I told her, “The issue isn’t that Muslims are ‘too religious.’ It’s that people are far too comfortable reducing 1.9 billion of us to the worst headlines they’ve read. No community is perfect. But you don’t get to label an entire faith violent because of the actions of a few — especially when that same faith explicitly condemns injustice, murder, cruelty, and arrogance.”
“When I hear kattar, I don’t think ‘violent.’ I think of someone rooted in faith — someone disciplined, not extreme. Someone who understands that being religious doesn’t mean forcing others to follow you, but living with integrity, mercy, and conscience. Like the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ.”
I shared a story with her — one that says more about Islam than any news report ever will.
Once, a poor man came to the Prophet ﷺ with a small gift of fruit. He was excited, proud, hoping to please him. The Prophet ﷺ ate the entire fruit himself — something very unusual, because he always shared with his companions. They were surprised. One finally asked him why he hadn’t shared this time.
He replied:

The fruit was sour.
I feared that if you tasted it, you might react,
and the man
would feel hurt.

That’s Islam. A faith so attentive to people’s feelings that the Prophet ﷺ would rather eat sour fruit alone than let someone’s dignity be bruised.
Islam is not just about rituals. It’s about how we treat each other — in private and in public. It’s about mercy, patience, and protecting the heart of another human being.
She replied, “But I’ve seen many Muslims act that way…”
I didn’t argue. Not because she was right — but because I realized she was speaking from what she’d been exposed to: not Islam, but a filtered, distorted image of Muslims shaped by violence, media, and bad actors. An image kept alive not by Muslims being too religious, but by a world that only sees us when there’s blood on the screen.
The Prophet ﷺ — the very figure people claim devout Muslims follow — never harmed anyone. He forgave those who tried to kill him. He stood up for women’s rights, protected orphans, shared his food, and worried about how his words might affect someone’s heart.
So the next time someone says “kattar Muslim” and means violent, harsh, or extreme — remember: that’s not Islam. That’s projection. That’s prejudice wearing the mask of opinion.

6 Comments

  1. Asadullah

    Beautifully written — a much-needed reminder that Islam is more than rituals, it’s a way of life rooted in mercy and compassion. This is exactly the kind of voice we need in today’s world of misconceptions.
    JazakAllahu Khair

    Reply
    • Aditi Prakash

      Your thoughts are commendable!!

      Reply
  2. Sweta

    Beautiful ,well written

    Reply
  3. Hasan N

    This is truly a deeply thoughtful matter, which has a profound connection with the real daily incidents of Muslim life

    Reply
  4. Your that friend

    Kattar….or deeply rooted to yours beliefs… impressive….. definitely a beutiful way to portray ❤️..

    Reply
  5. Kashif ul Islam

    Well articulated… keep sharing more… don’t pause here…

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *