Constitution Day is celebrated on 26th November annually to mark the adoption of the Indian Constitution in 1949, which came into effect on 26th January 1950. The Government of India declared the day in 2015 to promote constitutional values.
The Indian Constitution is the world’s largest written one, defining India as a sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic republic in the Preamble. It forms a Union of States without secession rights (Article 1), outlines citizenship rules (Articles 5-11), guarantees fundamental rights (Articles 12-35), and guides policies through Directive Principles (Articles 36-51). Citizens have fundamental duties (Article 51A), and there are provisions for reservations for backward classes (Articles 330-342) and recognition of 22 official languages (Articles 343-351). It includes emergency powers (Articles 352-360) and establishes an independent judiciary with the Supreme Court at the top. India’s Constitution is globally respected, though there has been concern about undue interference by the current BJP government, particularly regarding its impact on minorities.
The government’s approach to personal law reform, especially concerning Muslim laws, reflects a pattern of selectively targeting specific areas under the guise of progress. Historically, Muslim personal laws were respected, with the British leaving matters of family, inheritance, and marriage untouched while replacing Islamic criminal laws with the Indian Penal Code in 1862. The Shariat Act of 1937 maintained the integrity of Muslim personal laws in family matters. However, recent government actions, such as the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019, which criminalised instant triple talaq, seem less about genuine concern for women’s rights and more about gradually eroding the autonomy of personal laws. While reforms like the Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act 1939 were a necessary relief for women facing restrictive divorce laws, the pattern of interference raises concerns about the government’s intent. The focus appears to be on controlling and diminishing personal law under the pretext of empowerment without meaningful engagement with the affected communities. This selective intervention risks undermining religious freedoms and further polarising society.
The push for a Uniform Civil Code (UCC), as outlined in Article 44 of the Constitution, has long been a point of contention, especially within the Muslim community. This proposal, positioned as part of the Directive Principles of State Policy, is seen by many Muslims as a direct challenge to their laws, which they view as essential to their religious and cultural identity. From the very beginning, Muslims have opposed the UCC, fearing it would dismantle their autonomy over personal matters, despite assurances from figures like Dr B.R. Ambedkar, who suggested that the UCC would not be enforced without the community’s consent.
However, the current government’s rhetoric and actions seem to revive these fears, reinforcing the belief that there is a deliberate attempt to assimilate Muslims into a secular legal framework under the pretext of national unity. While a small segment of secular and modernist Muslims may support the UCC, the overwhelming opposition points to deeper concerns about religious freedom, cultural erosion, and the preservation of a distinct identity. Indian Muslims largely oppose the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) due to its perceived threat to their religious and cultural identity, with personal laws being central to Islamic life. Islam, meaning “submission to Allah,” governs all aspects of life, blending spiritual and worldly matters. Muslims believe their religion provides comprehensive guidance, including law, politics, and social conduct, making Islamic teachings inseparable from daily life.
Islamic law, or Shariah, is derived from the Quran and the Sunnah (the practices of the Prophet Muhammad, PBUH). It regulates family, economics, and even international relations. Fiqh, Islamic jurisprudence, allows for interpreting and applying Shariah in various contexts. The flexibility of Shariah is rooted in its ability to accommodate societal changes while maintaining core Islamic principles. Its sources—the Quran, Sunnah, Ijmaa (scholarly consensus), and Ijtihad (reasoned interpretation)—are sacred and central to the Muslim faith.
Muslim Personal Law, which covers family matters like marriage, divorce, and inheritance, is considered divine and integral to religious practice. For Muslims, disobedience to these laws is considered disobedience to Allah. Any attempt to alter these laws, such as the UCC, is viewed as a violation of religious freedom and an attack on their way of life.
Most of the opposition stems from distrust in the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government, particularly due to its stance on issues like triple talaq, waqf properties, and its push for states to stop funding madrasahs. The government’s criminalisation of instant triple talaq in 2019 was viewed by many Muslims not as a measure of women’s empowerment but as an attempt to interfere in Islamic marital laws. Similarly, controversies surrounding waqf properties, which are charitable endowments for religious or community purposes, have further fueled suspicions about the government’s intentions to undermine Muslim autonomy.
Additionally, the BJP’s insistence that state governments withdraw funding from madrasahs—Islamic educational institutions—has deepened the sense of marginalisation within the Muslim community. Madrasahs are viewed as crucial for religious education and cultural preservation. The perceived attack on these institutions, along with other legal interventions, leads Muslims to believe that the push for the UCC is less about national unity and more about gradually eroding their religious freedoms.
Thus, Muslims see the UCC as an attempt to assimilate them into a broader secular framework at the expense of their distinct identity. The BJP government’s actions on these sensitive issues create a deep sense of distrust and reinforce fears that their religious and cultural rights are under threat.
Criticism of Muslim Personal Law: A Focus on Marriage, Divorce, and Inheritance
Muslim Personal Law has been subjected to extensive criticism on three key issues: polygamy, divorce, and inheritance. Below is an organised review of the arguments and counterarguments surrounding these topics.
1. Polygamy: Polygamy is perhaps the most criticised aspect of Muslim Personal Law. The Quran allows a man to marry up to four women, as per the verse:
“And if ye fear that ye will not deal fairly by the orphans, marry of the women, who seem good to you, two or three or four, and if ye fear that ye cannot do justice (to so many) then one (only) or (captives) that your right hands possess. Thus it is more likely that ye will not do injustice.” (Quran IV:3)
Polygamy existed in many societies before Islam, including Jewish, Babylonian, and Hindu traditions. It was also accepted in Christianity before the advent of modern laws, showing that Islam did not introduce polygamy but rather regulated it by limiting the number of wives to four.
Proponents argue that polygamy provides a legal and protected environment for women, particularly in situations where men are naturally polygamous. It offers women dignity and security compared to being left vulnerable outside marriage. Critics, however, argue that polygamy is inherently discriminatory towards women. The counterpoint to this is that polygamy is not the rule in Islam but rather an exception permitted under certain conditions. Islamic scholars emphasize that monogamy is the default and polygamy is allowed only when justice can be ensured between the wives.
2. Divorce (Talaq): The Islamic law of divorce, specifically unilateral divorce (talaq) by the husband, has faced strong criticism. Critics argue that Muslim women suffer because the husband can pronounce divorce arbitrarily. There are multiple types of divorce in Islam, two being discussed here: Talaq al-Sunna. This is the preferred method of divorce, and it involves a slow, thoughtful process. It requires three separate pronouncements of talaq over three different periods of purity (tuhur), allowing time for reconciliation. Talaq al-Bid’a: This heretical form of divorce involves the pronouncement of three talaqs in one sitting, making it immediate and irrevocable.
The Quran advocates for reconciliation and peaceful resolution between spouses. It states: “And if ye fear a breach between husband and wife, send a judge out of his and another from her family: if they are desirous of agreement, God will effect a reconciliation between them.”(Quran VI:35)Islamic law includes several deterrents to prevent the abuse of divorce, such as dower (mahr), the practice of halala (remarriage after divorce), and talaq al-tawfid (delegated divorce).
3. Inheritance (Miras): The Islamic law of inheritance has also been criticized, particularly for its treatment of women, who receive half the share of their male counterparts. For example, a son inherits twice the share of a daughter.
Proponents of Islamic inheritance law argue that the system is fair when considering the overall economic responsibilities placed on men:
– A woman inherits not only from her father but also from her husband.
– She is entitled to a dower (mahr) from her husband, which remains her property.
– The financial responsibility of maintaining the wife and family lies entirely with the husband.
In addition, eight of the twelve Quranic sharers in inheritance are women, showing that women have significant rights to inheritance in Islamic law.
While Muslim Personal Law, particularly in the areas of polygamy, divorce, and inheritance, has been subject to criticism, proponents argue that these laws, as derived from the Quran and Islamic traditions, are based on principles of justice and equity.


0 Comments