Category : COVER STORY

Journalism is a field that is dependent on evolution. Much like literature or film, journalism cannot perform its function without engaging with an audience, and as the audience evolves, so must the medium. The latest evolution of journalism comes in the form of crisp 280-character Twitter (or now X, despite no one calling it that) bites and Instagram infographics. The nature of journalism in the social media era is succinct, easy & quick to absorb, owing to the declining attention span of us, the Tiktok-Instagram Reel-Youtube Short addicted public.

The reaction to this is often immediate and critical, with the idea that social media journalism is ridden with misinformation and designed more to entertain than to inform. While the concerns are valid, and the epidemic of misinformation is very real,
that perspective does not tell the full story. In my opinion, watering social media journalism down to political memes & attention-grabbing sound bites is a disservice. Vapid, sensationalised, only-for-entertainment journalism has always been part of the industry. For example, TMZ was recently put on blast for posting images of Liam Payne’s corpse, showing his tattoos for identification after his death. He died falling from a third story window, and while the picture was not explicit, it was suggestive. I do not think it bears explaining why posting an image of a man who met a violent death only hours before is in poor taste, but it accomplished the goal they wanted, it got more attention. Tabloids, paparazzi, and yellow journalism were a part of the industry before social media and even before the internet. So while it is true that social media journalism contains attention seeking posts, misinformation and distasteful coverage of sensitive topics, that does not take away from people working hard to bring ground news to the public.

Press of the People

The privatisation of news media in India is a great example of why social media journalism is relevant. In the past decade, the mainstream news media has been taken over by Hindutva sympathisers and enforcers. This has caused an exodus of left-leaning journalists from mainstream news outlets. Journalism is meant to be the fourth estate: the fourth pillar of the democratic government, the one that keeps it accountable. When the function of journalism is to speak truth to power, but their pockets are lined with the powers that be, where does one turn? Social media has become a sort of last refuge for aspiring journalists, journalists who have left mainstream media due to conflicting beliefs, and viewers who want a variety of viewpoints in their news alike. Like any other field of work, and especially one that has the power to influence political and social opinion in the public, Journalism has had a history of gatekeeping: who is allowed to be the bearer of news? Certainly, there are caveats, there are skills required to be a journalist, and not anyone can come into the newsroom off the street and write an Op-Ed. However, in the way gatekeeping tends to work, it disproportionately affects oppressed classes and prevents them from being a voice in the public sphere. What social media does is take away the gate.

The growing popularity of citizen journalism allows lay people to take an active role in disseminating news; especially if their circumstances make up the news. A Day in my Life videos & vlogs of people in warzones, live-tweeting Hurricane Helene, recordings by students during school shootings; it provides an authenticity to the reporting of events. Social media, since it began, has proven to be an excellent tool for accessibility. While minorities, poor people, people with disabilities and women often struggle to have their voices heard by mainstream media, social media provides a platform which does not require one to fit into a certain description to tell your story. Beyond that, it allows several people who, for whatever reason, were unable to be part of newsrooms to take part in the task of imparting news.

Places like Kashmir and the North East in India have experienced internet blackouts in an attempt to silence the reporting of the atrocities being committed there. In warzones, reporters are made to wear vests and travel in vehicles labelled Press. This is an attempt to protect them, to show that they are there to report the news and are not targets for either side. In Gaza, however, the Press label has become a bullseye. According to the count done by Reporters Without Borders, as of September 2024, over 130 journalists and media workers have been killed by the IDF since October 7th 2023. In such situations, it becomes obvious that the powers that be want to suppress news dissemination. However, with the advent of smartphones and social media, cameras and beacons are everywhere. It is impossible to actually keep the truth from the world.

Bisan Owda is a great example of this kind of citizen journalism. Journalism in the face of suppression of voices. She is a 27 year old Palestinian activist and citizen journalist, using her Instagram account (@wizard_bisan1) as a platform to put the cruelty and oppression of the Israeli regime on display. She posts the heartbreaking ground reality, videos of people struggling to find drinking water, children living through the war, statements from detainees etc. as well as fundraisers and pleas for action, like boycotts. Citizen journalism gives voice to those deliberately and maliciously quieted by people in power, and for that reason it is an invaluable tool.

The Filter Bubble Effect

Social media’s role in the spread of news has been increasing exponentially in the past decade. With it, the fear of fake news and ideological polarization is, too, on the rise. The importance of objectivity in the news comes to the forefront. Keeping the integrity of news in mind, as well as intending to reduce the incendiary nature of the way highly opinionated news spreads. The speed and accessibility of the internet poses a constant challenge to mainstream news sources. While a daily newspaper can only run a story the day after the event, Twitter will have it trending in a matter of minutes. Lately, more and more mainstream media has taken to curating an online presence. From local newspapers starting YouTube and journalists live-tweeting about events, it is fight for relevance. As previously stated, bias is not a new concept. However, while bias is media houses exist, media houses are still bound by the law to remain objective. So, while there may be obvious leanings among media houses, they still have to maintain a modicum of objectivity. Social media, on the other hand, has no such restrictions. Far from it, in fact. Social media have greatly exacerbated the era of fake news. The fact that fake news can spread so easily on social media only increases the worry that news reported by social media does not need to be objective

When studying journalism, one is taught that a part of maintaining journalistic integrity is to remain impartial. This is, of course, immediately followed up by the fact that it is impossible to remain truly impartial due to human nature and circumstance, but a journalist should attempt to do so to the best of his ability. This is an aspect of journalism that is lacking in citizen journalism. Without being beholden to a newsroom, one’s only allegiance is to oneself, and arguably, the public. It is expected that biases are visible in citizen journalism, often to the citizen journalists’ admittance. In a situation like Bisan, when mainstream media coverage is limited, and often times trivialising, it is completely understandable that it shows only the Palestinian side of the story. The mouse cannot be expected to tell the cats’ story just to be fair. As the Adam Bates quote goes, “You can say ‘all are welcome’ but if wolves and sheep are both welcome, you’re only going to get wolves. Then the smart sheep will go somewhere else and the naive sheep will be eaten and processed. If you welcome Islamophobes and Muslims, you’ll get Islamophobes.”

One may say that the obvious solution to that is to diversify the sources one gets news from. However, at the crux of the issue is the fact that social media was not designed to be a news platform. With algorithms designed to optimize user experience by filtering out content according to their likes and dislikes, it poses a danger to objectivity. Social media shows you more of the content that you that you engage with, meaning if you like, comment or share something, you’re more likely to see videos with the same topics and tags. This creates these sort of echo chambers of like-minded people who are most likely to see only one side of the story, reinforcing their existing beliefs. This is called the Filter Bubble Effect, like filter bubbles in fish tank rising to the top. The filter bubble effect has become so prominent in the modern age, that it has been added to the Oxford dictionary. According to Oxford, the filter bubble effect is defined as: “A situation in which an internet user encounters only information and opinions that conform to and reinforce their own beliefs, caused by algorithms that personalize an individual’s online experience.” Combatting the Filter Bubble Effect, as well as the constant barrage of misinformation is essential, and perhaps the greatest challenge to social media journalism.

Doom scrolling

The news is, by nature, constant. A constant, never-ending barrage of the worst things happening in the world, on a device that is constantly in your hand, and a public that continually demands that you not only keep up with it, but react and have an opinion on everything. An aptly named phenomenon, doomscrolling or doomsurfing, is defined as, “The act of spending an excessive amount of time reading large quantities of news, particularly negative news, on the web and social media.” An unprecedented effect, but an important one, in my opinion, of social media being used to disseminate news is that a continuous flood of negative information has a poor effect on the psyche.

While slogans like “They are living a life you cannot bear to watch” are both catchy and true, it plays into the social media trend to make the lay person responsible for bearing witness. Social media has a tendency to make people feel like they are in the spotlight, a sort of anxiety that if you do not react immediately and correctly to every single thing happening in the world, then people will not know where your allegiances lie. Perhaps bearing witness is all you are able to do in the face of everything that is happening in the world, but that, too, cannot be constant. As a spectator, one must allow oneself grace and time to process so one can put their best into serving society.

Journalism continues to evolve, and perhaps as time passes, we as a society will find ways to combat these challenges. Until then, keep an open mind, confuse your social media algorithms, and always, always check your facts.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *