The author is a renowned journalist
Denial of Bail to Student Activists
By denying bail to student activists Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam, and seven others accused in the February 2020 anti-Muslim North East Delhi riots “Larger Conspiracy” case, the Delhi High Court has blindly endorsed trumped-up prosecution charges and committed a grave injustice.
A division bench of the Delhi High Court, comprising Justices Naveen Chawla and Shalinder Kaur, gave the verdict on the bail applications on Tuesday, 2nd September 2025. The other accused in the so-called conspiracy case are Athar Khan, Khalid Saifi, Mohamed Saleem Khan, Shifa ur Rehman, Meeran Haider, Gulfisha Fatima, and Shadab Ahmed.
Disproportionate Targeting of Muslims
What is very disturbing to any independent observer of the ongoing cases related to the 2020 Delhi riots is that most cases are against Muslims. An analysis of riot-related cases reveals that the Muslims were disproportionately targeted. The riots occurred largely in Muslim-dominated areas, where most of the victims were also Muslims. Muslims bore the brunt of the violence, with properties and even mosques being destroyed during protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), which discriminated against Muslims. Out of the 53 people killed in the riots, 40 were Muslims. Out of the 18 charged under the Conspiracy case, 16 are Muslims.
Questionable Disclosure Statements
A review of disclosure statements made by persons accused of various offenses under both the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and the draconian Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) has revealed a troubling pattern. While some disclosure statements are consistent from beginning to end, many have identical paragraphs across different accused. Clearly, these statements were either fabricated or the accused were coached under threat of torture.
For instance, Meeran Haider’s disclosure statement recorded on 8 April 2020 is word-for-word identical to Safoora Zargar’s statement of 14 April 2020, except for the names. Similarly, statements of Shadab Ahmed, Salim Malik, and Athar Khan, recorded on 27 May, 28 June, and 3 July 2020, respectively, along with Mohammed Salim Khan’s undated statement, are identical to Natasha Narwal’s and Devangana Kalita’s statements recorded on 7 June 2020. In a further mockery of the process, identical grammatical errors appear in statements from different accused on different dates.
These statements cannot be relied upon to convict a person. However, they are gravely prejudicial and are sufficient for denying bail under UAPA, leading to long periods of incarceration without trial. Umar Khalid and others accused in the “Larger Conspiracy” case have been in prison for almost five years.
Misuse of UAPA and Delayed Trial
Investigations in the Conspiracy case under UAPA have been plagued by “staggered” arrests, resulting in inordinate delays in trial. After the initial 180 days for filing the chargesheet for the first set of accused, subsequent sets are arrested, followed by third and even fourth sets. This deliberate staggering delays the trial and keeps the accused in jail without trial or bail for years.
It is clear that the police and prosecution are misusing UAPA not to convict the accused, but to keep them incarcerated indefinitely. The legal process itself has become a form of punishment without conviction in the conspiracy case against Muslims.
Flawed Legal Reasoning in Bail Rejection
In rejecting the bail applications, the Delhi High Court has effectively turned criminal jurisprudence upside down. After hearing arguments from Solicitor General (SG) of India Tushar Mehta, opposing bail based on mere conjecture, the Court reserved its order without giving the accused an opportunity to contest the SG’s submissions.
In his submission, Tushar Mehta linked PhD student Sharjeel Imam’s speeches to US President Donald Trump’s visit to India, without any evidence. The SG claimed that Imam’s reference to “four weeks” on 23 January 2020 indicated a timeline for executing the conspiracy.
In reality, the “four weeks” referred to the Supreme Court’s deadline given to the Union Government on 22 January 2020 to respond to over 100 petitions challenging the CAA—a law that for the first time made religion the basis of Indian citizenship. Imam first spoke of this in Asansol, West Bengal, on 22 January 2020, wondering what might happen in Assam and Uttar Pradesh during this period. He spoke again in Gaya, Bihar, on 23 January 2020, criticizing Supreme Court judgments on Triple Talaq and the Babri Masjid-Ram Temple case.
By no stretch of imagination can Imam’s “four weeks” be linked to Trump’s visit, which was publicly announced only on 11 February 2020. Imam was arrested by Delhi police on 28 January 2020—two weeks prior to the announcement.
The Delhi police claimed that anti-CAA protests were a front for planning riots and organizing roadblocks that could turn violent during Trump’s visit “to globally defame our nation.”
Contradiction with Earlier Bail Orders
In this context, the bench of Justices Chawla and Kaur deliberately ignored the Delhi High Court’s earlier observations when granting bail to Devangana Kalita, Natasha Narwal, and Asif Iqbal Tanha in June 2021. The Court had stated that, “shorn of the superfluous verbiage, hyperbole, and stretched inferences, there was no case of terrorist activity, and the State has blurred the line between the constitutionally guaranteed right to protest and terrorist activity.”
Justices Sidharth Mridul and Anup Jairam Bhambhani had observed that “making inflammatory speeches and organizing chakka jams are not uncommon when there is widespread opposition to governmental or parliamentary actions.”
Bail as the Rule, Not the Exception
The High Court order denying bail to nine accused, who have been in jail for nearly five years, comes despite repeated emphasis on bail by the Chief Justice of India, B.R. Gavai. On 7 July 2025, he observed that the judiciary had “somewhat forgotten” the cardinal legal principle that bail is the rule and jail is the exception.


0 Comments