Author : Sumna Sadaqat

The author is a postgraduate in Islamic Studies from University of Birmingham, UK.

Accusations that theQur’an, the foundational text of Islam promotes Anti-Semitism has gained traction in modern political discourse. But before evaluating such claims, it is
important to break down the word & understand that its origin goes back to modern Europe.
After unpacking this historical baggage associated with the term, we must explore whether this 7th century text is hostile towards the Jewish community.

Before understanding ‘Anti-Semitism’ in theQur’an, the word anti-Semitism must be described appropriately. This term has been used since the 19th century. Academics, politicians, activists and theologians have employed it variedly and sometimes contradictorily. The term’s complex usage and contested definition makes it difficult to expound a singular relationship between it and theQur’an. Thus, the first step is to understand what this term Anti-Semitism means, and what are its implications before heading onto finding it in the Qur’an.

Firstly, the word ‘Semite’ refers to a language family, rather than a religious group or race. Arabic, Hebrew, Aramaic, and Amharic amongst others are included in this cluster. Scholars such as Edward Said and Brian Klung pointed this out. Thus, they considered Antisemitism as a misnomer. They argued it to be etymologically misleading. But most scholars understand that its usage by the German journalist and politician Wilhelm Marr has laid the foundation of its usage in the current context. Marr, in 1879 constructed a pseudo-scientific racial theory according to which ‘Semites’ or Jews were considered different and inferior. He considered that their nature could never change. This definition has primarily set the premise of using the term Antisemitism now. Thus, it is described as Jewish-hatred, hostility towards, prejudice and discrimination against Jews.

In 1985, Bat Ye’or, a Swiss-Egyptian writer known for her polemical works on Islam and minority relations, argued that the Islamic scriptures provide Jews with an institutionalized inferior status. Author Andrew Bostom (2008) posits that Antisemitism is rooted in Islamic scripture. In his work he argues that the foundational Islamic texts contain repeated negative stereotypes and accusations against Jews while promoting Jewish hatred. Similarly, the activist David Littman claimed that theQur’an contains Antisemitic language in the UN human Rights commission proceedings.

But most of these voices are either selective in picking up verses or interpret the text without the proper context, misconstruing the original scripture. These arguments are also often tinted with political and/or historical factors, rendering them erroneous. Most importantly, some of these voices are more pronounced because of their constant critique and hatred of Islam. Many academics on the contrary, have thus applied a nuanced and balanced approach on the subject. For instance, Fred Donner (2010), a renowned scholar of Islam does not call theQur’an Antisemitic, rather suggests that some verses referring to Jews, describing their flaws are explicitly referring to Jews of Medina at that time, and not to the entire community (Quran: 2:75–79, 2:88–91, 5:13–15, 62:5).  Franz Rosenthal in his work on “The Influence of the Bible on Islamic Culture” observed that the portrayal of Jews in theQur’an can be harsh, but it’s largely a theological polemic and not a racial one.

There are several clear examples in theQur’an, which suggest that theQur’an is not antisemitic.

Firstly, theQur’an discusses Prophets of ‘Jewish’ originat length and honours and praises each one of them (38:17–26, 27:15–44, 12:1-111, 38:45–47). Prophet Moses/ Musa is mentioned 136 times in the entire text and is praised extensively (7:143–145). It also encourages Believers to respect all the Prophets (2:285). Similarly, it describes the holy places of Jews as sacred lands of worship (5:21). The verses suggesting the change in direction of prayers from Jerusalem to Mecca came approximately 13-14 years after Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) received the first revelation (2:142–145). Until then, Muslims continued to pray in the direction of Jerusalem. In fact, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) continued to reiterate the importance of the holy land of Palestine and encouraged Muslims to visit and pray in the premises which is recorded in Hadith literature. TheQur’an amply describes the lands where Prophets Abraham, Issac, Joseph, Jonah, Moses, David, Solomon, Joshua (PBUT) amongst others lived and guided humanity and calls it a blessed land. Besides, the Qur’an always encourages Jews to read and follow their own scriptures and even mentions the Ten commandments which were given to Moses (PBUH) (5:43–47, 7:145, 6:151–153). Apart from this, theQur’an reemphasizes that they were the chosen people (2:47) who were granted various favours of God. But it completes its narrative by also discussing their mistakes, problems and misdoings at length (2:61, 2:75–79, 5:64). Again, it does not generalize, rather differentiates between the righteous and transgressors (3:113–115). It also makes sure that their errors are cited as examples to extract lessons from for Muslims and humanity in general, rather than treating them as a community which should be demonized or discriminated against.

Besides,Qur’an (3:64) calls on interfaith dialogue between monotheistic religions and shows the desire of the text to reach a common ground rather than promote conflict or differences. This clearly contradicts the notion of antisemitism in theQur’an.

Another important point to be highlighted is what theQur’an never says about the Jews. Academic Reuven Firestone has made a key observation in this regard. He notes that by looking at what theQur’an does not say about Jews, the true Islamic thinking on Jews is also partially revealed. He suggests that theQur’an never calls Jews Satan, compares them with devils or calls them anything demeaning or dehumanizing. Nor does theQur’an ever ask Muslims to kill or exterminate the Jews. This according to him proves that theQur’an is not antisemitic.

What it does is criticize their evil practices or comment on their flaws and misinterpretations of God’s words. It also asks them to look into their own texts and return to the true path that God asked them to follow. It also especially scrutinizes the behaviour of the clergy and the learned Jewish Rabbis (9:34) holds them accountable and asks them to return to the true religion. Thus, the narrative of theQur’an nowhere regards Jews as inferior as a race or religious community.

In summary, the text of theQur’an is neither etymologically nor theologically prejudiced against the Jews. It perfectly balances, while critiquing and appreciating the Jews as required. The charge of antisemitism being promoted in the text is therefore an unsubstantial charge against theQur’an- which as a source of guidance for humanity advises people to make better choices in life. It calls humanity, irrespective of the various religious affiliations, to reflect on the past and build a healthier future. Going through the Qur’an with a biased lens risks undermining its moral complexity and stripping it off of the core values of justice and shared prophetic legacy that it undoubtedly upholds.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *